Showing posts sorted by date for query horn book. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query horn book. Sort by relevance Show all posts

December 18, 2011

Of Michael Best's "horn book" Civil Procedure

Looky here:
Because the Wisconsin Supreme Court tied over the ethics complaint, Gableman couldn't argue to the board that he had won and the State should cover his fees, Michael Best & Friedrich's chief attorney Jonathan Margolies said in the letter.
Well. Isn't that something. I have been saying for years that Mike Gableman failed to win his ethics case, because the three-judge panel below the Supreme Court convened on Gableman's motion for summary judgment, and pursuant to his own motion, Gableman was unsuccessful. And it also happens to be a conclusion in which Justice N. Patrick Crooks, who has been a judge for more than three decades, concurs.

(I reckon Crooks, J. knows a thing or eleventeen about legal procedure.)

Therefore does the ethics complaint against Gableman remain pending.

Mr. Margolies might presumably know better than anybody, as it was one of his colleagues at Michael Best who participated in Gableman's defense.* This space's conclusion was based on an examination of the statutory framework governing the civil procedure with which the State deals with ethics allegations against judges. This space does not make substantive legal claims without having undertaken such examinations.

So it amuses me no end to recall that Richard Esenberg, a professor of the law at Marquette University, would criticize me by asserting that my view of the Gableman case's procedural posture was informed merely by "a reference to horn book Civil Procedure" which "does not cut it here."

A "horn book" is something like a Cliff's Notes that first-year law students use to prepare for exams. Esenberg is billed as a "prominent Milwaukee attorney" by Wisconsin Public Radio but his condescension on occasion most certainly does not comport with that description.

Now perhaps Esenberg can direct his scorn at MB&F's chief attorney.

I am always suspicious of Esenberg's claims, and you should be too. Yet Wisconsin Public Radio and other local media outlets continue to present him as a disinterested academic, whereas he's as partisan as they come.

Esenberg's former research assistant's claims are mighty lame as well.**

Feet of the master and all that, apparently. Laughable.

* At no charge, as it turns out. And a classy defense it was indeed.

** I trust that was the end of atrocious legal analysis from the faculty blog, since Prof. Esenberg is abdicated as one of the website's editors.

April 1, 2011

Right-wing condescension in Wisconsin, Day Two

CAPITOL KAOS, Agent Rick reporting for Faux News duty

I finally had a chance to listen to Joy Cardin's March 30 interview with Marquette professors of law Ed Fallone and Rick Esenberg, discussing the events unfolding in Judge Maryann Sumi's courtroom in Madison. The link is here, and it's about 35 minutes. Prof. Fallone has got it together, and you'll hear little more from him than you've already read on this here blog over the past week, starting last Friday.

Esenberg, on the other hand, is priceless, so desperately does he want it to be 1943, when the Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled that a dicey procedure* in a political branch might not be enjoined.

But much has changed since then, most importantly the enactment of the Open Meetings Law, which set in place a number of directives to the courts that make Prof. Esenberg's 1943 case considerably less significant than he makes it out to be. But Prof. Esenberg is having none of it, and literally sneers at anyone who thinks differently.

But first, Esenberg has apparently forgotten about the chicanery perpetrated by the Republican Senate leader Scott Fitzgerald, who Esenberg helped advise that a six-months-pregnant woman might be "carried ... feet first" over that legislative chamber's threshold:
The mess that we find ourselves in now is because, I believe, that the circuit court failed to give adequate attention to whether or not this was a morass into which she should have plunged in the first place.
It's laugh-out-loud stuff, and the gist of Esenberg's complaint is that Judge Sumi hasn't explained to Esenberg every step of her reasoning up to this point: Rick is "extremely disappointed" that Judge Sumi hasn't acknowledged Rick's concerns, which is absolute nonsense because the one case upon which Rick hangs his hat is referenced throughout documents filed with the court, including, significantly, the District IV Court of Appeals certification of Ozanne v. Fitz to the Supreme Court. Rick suggests Sumi is simply ignoring it. Poor guy.

And unfortunately for Prof. Rick, it isn't the only case.

Another thing that bothers Rick is that Dane County District Attorney Ismail Ozanne didn't sue the Legislative Reference Bureau along with the secretary of state. But if your objective is to enjoin publication, which is a legal term of art and is what is required by the constitution and the statutory framework, then why would you sue the Kinko's kiosk?** This concern catapults Prof. Esenberg into full sneer-mode:
The one thing I think should have happened here is that a lawyer who read the law, and I'm talking about the statutes and, y'know, not a publication that is sent to schoolchildren to explain to gradeschoolers how, y'know, a law goes into effect, but actually read the law ...
And if you think "sneering" is an exaggeration, go to 32:45 of the interview. Evidently invoking "schoolchildren" is a rhetorical specialty of Rick's, because he pulled the same stunt on me when I pointed out that Michael Gableman's ethics case was still pending after the Supreme Court delivered its opinions — or "writings," as they have become known — in the matter. Rick told me I needed to consult something other than "horn book" civil procedure, which is like accusing someone of only having read the CliffsNotes version of The Brothers Karamazov or, as Rick would put it: "[G]o read Sartre."

But then, lo and behold, Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice N. Patrick Crooks, who has been a trial judge and an appellate judge for 30-plus years, appeared before a special committee of the legislature to point out that, yes, the complaint against Gableman is still pending because — just as this space had explained earlier — Gableman failed to win his motion for summary judgment, which is the question an appeals court panel had convened to hear in September of 2009.

So, yes, I had certainly consulted something other than a horn book: I consulted something called the law prior to making the claim, as did Justice Crooks prior to affirming it, as has, obviously, Judge Maryann Sumi. She's not conducting this hearing — and they call them hearings for a reason — for the special benefit of Marquette's Rick Esenberg.

Rick has a right to his argument — which is wrong, as it turns out — but he has no cause to sneer and especially no business sneering at a presiding trial judge simply because she hasn't acknowledged Prof. Rick's existence. The hubris, as they say, is strong with this one.

But the truly depressing thing is, the local nut-right simply accepts Prof. Esenberg's words as Gospel, and his sentiment find its way into the appalling personal attacks against Judge Sumi among the basest dregs of the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel's comments threads.

Meanwhile what Judge Maryann Sumi is doing is an exemplary job and she's clearly — crystal clearly — been doing her homework.

* There is procedure and there is substance, a fundamental distinction in all law, and a very important distinction in this case. It's why the Justices of the SCOTUS were moved to devise the intuitively redundant expression, "procedural due process."

** No disrespect to the LRB, but it's the best metaphor I can think of to describe a core question of the case. Amusingly, Esenberg accuses the LRB of injecting politics into the proceeding when in fact the LRB is the least political party, named or unnamed, to the proceeding.

September 17, 2010

Wisconsin Supreme Court quote of the day

Justice N. Patrick Crooks, 08/05/10:
I don't think that the Gableman decision provided a final resolution of the charges that were brought by the [Wisconsin Judicial Commission] and that are pending against Justice Gableman. Why do I say that? Well, I say that because, if you look closely — and I'm sure you have — at what the Judicial Commission did, they did not dismiss the charges against Justice Gableman. They did not do what several of us suggested was appropriate and request a jury trial in regard to those issues. Rather, what they did was suspend the prosecution. And I think that that provides an opportunity for the legislature to act in regard to the appropriate procedure. I certainly think that the allegations against Justice Ziegler led to a final resolution. But I don't see a final resolution with regard to the situation with Justice Gableman. And I think I have to bring that to the committee and that's where Justice Roggensack and I disagree.

What happened is that in front of the panel, the three-judge panel, Justice Gableman through his attorney brought a motion for summary judgment, basically asking that the charges against Justice Gableman be dismissed. The three-judge panel held oral arguments in regard to that motion for summary judgment. And their recommendation to the court was that we should grant that motion for summary judgment. So what comes to us, in my view and the view of the colleagues that have sided with me was pure and simply, we're looking again now at that recommendation for a grant of summary judgment. Summary judgment was not granted. As you know, we split 3-3. The division, in my opinion, caused a deadlock. Summary judgment was not granted. It certainly therefore failed, in terms of the request that summary judgment be granted.

Now, what normally happens — and bear with me for a minute — normally what happens if you're in a civil court situation — and by the way as you know the Judicial Commission, the rules and the statutes in regard to the Judicial Commission talk about operating under the civil rules. But what happens in a normal situation where someone brings a motion for summary judgment and the summary judgment motion is not granted, or [is] denied, or fails, is there's a trial. And three of us, looking at the statutes, looking at the interplay of the statutes, felt that it was appropriate for the Judicial Commission to go back to the point where they'd made a determination of probable cause, which I think they made probably about a year-and-a-half ago, and at that point, take the other route.

The route that they took at the time was the three-judge panel. The three-judge panel approach didn't resolve this issue. And so the other approach that's available, in our opinion, under the statutes, was the jury trial. And we suggested strongly to the Judicial Commission that they take that route. Now, the Judicial Commission, in the statement that they issued saying that they were suspending prosecution of the matter, indicated they felt there was a need for clarification in regard to the statutes. In other words, they didn't think that the procedure was as clear-cut as they would have liked it to have been.

And I will just tell you, speaking not only for myself but I think clearly for the Chief Justice and for Justice Bradley, we certainly would have no objection if this committee, and ultimately the legislature, were to attempt to clarify to the extent desired by the Judicial Commission. I don't think that's necessary, but I certainly don't object to it.
Sounds familiar.

I wonder if our friend professor of law Richard Esenberg took the opportunity to also instruct Justice Crooks, who has been a trial and appellate judge for 34 years, that his and the two other Justices' view of the case's procedural posture is informed merely by "a reference to horn book Civil Procedure" which "does not cut it here." I doubt it.

August 19, 2010

This week in Prof. Rick's horn book Earth sciences

File under — #blamesunspots

Dadgummit, it's those local bloggers again, and they're chortling!

This week Prof. Rick reminds us that measurements in solar activity are indeed taken into consideration by scientists when formulating calculations, algorithms, and computer modeling related to assessing the effects of heat* trapped by greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.

Even for fallible scientists, that fiery orb is mighty difficult to ignore.

Thanks, Prof. Rick, for the enlightenment. Unfortunately Prof. Rick's blinding glimpses of the obvious and his links to newspaper opinion columns do zero work by way of validating Republican candidate Ron Johnson's assertion that it's "far more likely it's just sunspot activity" that's causing observed increases in global temperatures.

Nor does Prof. Rick venture to undertake a defense of Ron Johnson's much wilder claim that excess carbon dioxide in the Earth's atmosphere "gets sucked down by trees and helps the trees grow."

Given the dramatically inverse relationship between increasing carbon emissions and reducing global forestation, perhaps engaging that sparkling gem of scientific reasoning far exceeded even Prof. Rick's formidable powers of conservative Republican apologetic.

In the meantime it seems unlikely that Ron Johnson places his bonsai tree collection beneath the tailpipe of an idling Escalade overnight.

Nor would he sit in a chamber pumped full of "excess" carbon dioxide.

* Heat, as contrasted with temperature, which makes Prof. Rick's attempted funny at Russ Feingold's expense fall completely flat.

eta: "It's an important point," sez funnyman and dendrochronologist Patrick McIlheran. Yes. Hard to believe nobody thought of it before.

July 29, 2010

Prof. Rick's horn book statement of facts

Not even the public defender will come to the aid of Steve Doocy:
[Fox News] did not run it until after Sherrod was fired.
"I had to read it twice to makes sure that it wasn't satire."
— Prof. Rick

July 19, 2010

Prof. Rick's horn book writing and research

Prof. Rick is skeptical Republican/Fox News/BP candidate for Senate Ron Johnson ever said he wanted to open up the Great Lakes to oil & gas drilling. "His answer did not mention the Great Lakes but the question to which he was responding is said to have used the Great Lakes as an example — although I have yet to see anyone reproduce it and it now seems to be behind WisPolitics' pay wall," alleges Rick.

No it ain't. June 10, 2010:
WISPOLITICS: Do you want to open up more of the United States to drilling? I mean, would you support drilling like in the Great Lakes, for example, if there was oil found there, or more exploration in Alaska, ANWR, those kinds of things?

RON JOHNSON: Y'know, the bottom line is that we are an oil-based economy. We're really, there's nothing we're going to do to get off of that for many, many years. So I mean we just have to, we have to be realistic and recognize that fact and I think we have to get the oil where it is ...
"Like in the Great Lakes, for example." That was the question.

To be fair, Ron Johnson doesn't know where the Great Lakes are.

July 8, 2010

Snark (and Shepherd) of the day

"A reference to horn book Civil Procedure does not cut it here."

I lol'd.

And take solace in the fact that even a former Supreme Court Justice and former Dean of the Marquette law school, Prof. Janine Geske, is similarly unsure as to the case's procedural posture at this point.

What one really needs to be skeptical of are Prof. Esenberg's conclusory pronouncements, not openminded contemplations of possible procedural alternatives going forward. (And I don't rely on any horn book for that view, as I've never owned one in my life.)

Prof. Esenberg, it's useful to recall, assisted in enabling Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce to wage its multi-million-dollar political campaign against Justice Louis Butler. WMC even named its campaign after one of Prof. Esenberg's Federalist Society memorandums, and Prof. Esenberg (and McIlheran) went to bat repeatedly for one of Louis Butler's most scurrilous attackers. As such, he's not exactly a disengaged academic observer.

And, thanks to that torrent of politically motivated B.S. raised against Justice Butler, the nomination of this principled, capable, and highly qualified judge to the federal district court flounders still among a gaggle of disingenuous Republican hacks in the U.S. Senate.

Gableman's "distasteful" escapades pale in comparison to that effect.