The GOP's David Prosser Dilemma:
Is recounting votes a gigantic, waste-of-time pain in the ass, or is it a gratuitously expensive, gigantic, waste-of-time pain in the ass?
TMJ-4's Sunday INCITE! with Charlie McSykes is a Journal Communications, Inc. Joint
Showing posts sorted by date for query Sunday INCITE!. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Sunday INCITE!. Sort by relevance Show all posts
April 24, 2011
April 3, 2011
Shorter Sunday INCITE!
Charlie Sykes: Kloppenburg is "using" Merryfield against Prosser.*
Jeff Fleming: Prosser called the Chief Justice a bitch.
Charlie Sykes: Don't change the subject.
For a lot of people, that is the subject.
Sunday INCITE! is a Journal Communications, Inc. Joint
Me and the Brew City Brawler oughta have our own radio show.
Now that would kick ass.
* It's not Kloppenburg's ad, it's third-party. And Mr. Merryfield said all the documented stuff in the ad, but recanted as soon as it appeared.
Very strange.
Jeff Fleming: Prosser called the Chief Justice a bitch.
Charlie Sykes: Don't change the subject.
For a lot of people, that is the subject.
Sunday INCITE! is a Journal Communications, Inc. Joint
Me and the Brew City Brawler oughta have our own radio show.
Now that would kick ass.
* It's not Kloppenburg's ad, it's third-party. And Mr. Merryfield said all the documented stuff in the ad, but recanted as soon as it appeared.
Very strange.
In Re:
WISCT 2011
June 19, 2010
Wisconsin conservatives go following the logic
Reasons top Wisconsin conservative blogger Owen Robinson:
So let me see if I have this straight.
1) A gang of initially non-credible right-wing mischief makers with a political axe to grind — together with the kind assistance of Journal Broadcast Group howler/blogger Charlie Sykes — threw this scam against the wall based on nothing but "an analysis of time stamps."
2) "An analysis of time stamps is pretty stupid."
3) This particular "analysis of time stamps" is so "pretty stupid" that even casual observers were able to blow its phony implications out of the water without the help of the district attorney's office.
4) Nevertheless, anything even this "pretty stupid" is representative of "enough probable cause" to launch a criminal investigation.
That's right, a criminal investigation.
No wonder Owen Robinson is a frequent guest on Charlie Sykes's dreary teevee show, Sunday INCITE! These are the same folks in constant outrage-mode on the subject of unchecked state power.
Yet here is Owen Robinson essentially justifying a police state.
Furthermore, according to Robinson's "logic," even Liebenthal's blog posts time-stamped in the late evening hours and on weekends (which is practically all of them*) may also be grounds for a criminal investigation because "I can put whatever time I want on a post."
Think that's stretching an inference? Read on.
Another of Robinson's fellow travelers claims it's "fairly obvious" Chris Liebenthal was posting to his blog on county time. His own "probable cause" for this claim? That Liebenthal is so prolific, he couldn't possibly have composed his blog posts on his own time: Yes, an "impossible feat," he says, unless Liebenthal didn't have a job at all.
Ergo, he must have been committing a crime, and not just a State crime, but a federal crime. (His "wet dream" is projected here.)
Jeremy "Rhymes With Clown" Shown, one of the few coherently thoughtful local conservative bloggers, asks:
Robinson's blog, incidentally, served as the host to an especially scurrilous libel masquerading as a "leak" from the DA's office that elicited** correspondence from the defamed party's counsel.
And by the way, don't miss visiting the recently updated "Boots & Kittens," John Foust's dryly whimsical Owen Robinson parody.
Foust has been banned from commenting at Robinson's website, yet Robinson's comments policy allows for publishing the most revolting of falsehoods directed at Chris Liebenthal. Figure that one out.
* Chris occasionally comments at this here blog, invariably in the late evening hours and on weekends, all compelling confirmations of when he's active updating his own blogs. I have all the comments, along with the separate Gmail notifications of the comments, numerous instances where it seems to me time stamps are not "pretty stupid," nor would I have the faintest idea how to manipulate them.
** Or "illicited," if one is thus inclined (read BCB's header).
The thing is ... an analysis of time stamps is pretty stupid. I can put whatever time I want on a post. I think the time stamps perhaps give enough probable cause to investigate whether or not a crime (or at least a work ruled violation) has occurred, but it’s certainly not evidence.The ellipsis is his.
So let me see if I have this straight.
1) A gang of initially non-credible right-wing mischief makers with a political axe to grind — together with the kind assistance of Journal Broadcast Group howler/blogger Charlie Sykes — threw this scam against the wall based on nothing but "an analysis of time stamps."
2) "An analysis of time stamps is pretty stupid."
3) This particular "analysis of time stamps" is so "pretty stupid" that even casual observers were able to blow its phony implications out of the water without the help of the district attorney's office.
4) Nevertheless, anything even this "pretty stupid" is representative of "enough probable cause" to launch a criminal investigation.
That's right, a criminal investigation.
No wonder Owen Robinson is a frequent guest on Charlie Sykes's dreary teevee show, Sunday INCITE! These are the same folks in constant outrage-mode on the subject of unchecked state power.
Yet here is Owen Robinson essentially justifying a police state.
Furthermore, according to Robinson's "logic," even Liebenthal's blog posts time-stamped in the late evening hours and on weekends (which is practically all of them*) may also be grounds for a criminal investigation because "I can put whatever time I want on a post."
Think that's stretching an inference? Read on.
Another of Robinson's fellow travelers claims it's "fairly obvious" Chris Liebenthal was posting to his blog on county time. His own "probable cause" for this claim? That Liebenthal is so prolific, he couldn't possibly have composed his blog posts on his own time: Yes, an "impossible feat," he says, unless Liebenthal didn't have a job at all.
Ergo, he must have been committing a crime, and not just a State crime, but a federal crime. (His "wet dream" is projected here.)
Jeremy "Rhymes With Clown" Shown, one of the few coherently thoughtful local conservative bloggers, asks:
[Liebenthal's] got an anti-Walker fixation that comes perilously close to "he doth protest too much," and the best the Walker supporters can muster is sending the DA to confiscate the computer from his workplace at the county to make sure he wasn't blogging on county time? ...Certainly not if Owen Robinson is its leading light.
Can't the Walker camp come up with some smart folks to simply counter the pronouncements that [Liebenthal] makes on his blog?
Robinson's blog, incidentally, served as the host to an especially scurrilous libel masquerading as a "leak" from the DA's office that elicited** correspondence from the defamed party's counsel.
And by the way, don't miss visiting the recently updated "Boots & Kittens," John Foust's dryly whimsical Owen Robinson parody.
Foust has been banned from commenting at Robinson's website, yet Robinson's comments policy allows for publishing the most revolting of falsehoods directed at Chris Liebenthal. Figure that one out.
* Chris occasionally comments at this here blog, invariably in the late evening hours and on weekends, all compelling confirmations of when he's active updating his own blogs. I have all the comments, along with the separate Gmail notifications of the comments, numerous instances where it seems to me time stamps are not "pretty stupid," nor would I have the faintest idea how to manipulate them.
** Or "illicited," if one is thus inclined (read BCB's header).
April 10, 2010
Local clown will convene his circus tomorrow
Wow, what a balanced lineup. Should be a great debate.Was Dad29 busy?*
Actually, Mikel Holt is sensible and considerably less of a personal masseuse to Charlie Sykes, but the others never listen to him.
Because then they might have to jabber something other than what they found in their National Review Online RSS feed instructions.
* Sunday INCITE! tapes during the 10:15 at Our Blessed Lady of Perpetual Conservative Republican Dyspepsia, Goerkes Corners.
See also: WTMJ power goes out on wrong day of week
March 7, 2010
Area man actually watches Sunday Incite!
And the review is in:
well i can see where the people on that panel get their news: each other. just a bunch of yes men to other yes men.joel olsteen nails it.
October 17, 2009
Even the wingers are weary of Sykes
"Right-wing guy" Patrick McIlheran, advertising tomorrow's appearance with a bunch of other "right-wing persons" on Charlie Sykes's low-rent squawk-fest Sunday INCITE!, is garrulously chided:
As is the television viewing audience.
You have Obama turning the country socialist and you clowns get distracted by shiny objects. Why not spend a day talking about Balloon Boy and American Idol while you are at it.American Idol is already Ann Althouse's bag, I believe. "Is the NFL better off" for its rejection of their hero, Rush Limbaugh, wonders McIlheran and his right-wing pals. Considering Sunday INCITE! goes head to head with Sunday NFL Countdown on ESPN, I'd say, yeah.— A. Conservative
As is the television viewing audience.
October 12, 2008
Sad and lazy clowns
This morning on his popular teevee programme Sunday INCITE!, host Charlie Sykes predicted that once Barack Obama gets elected president of the United States and the "elite mainstream media" finally gets around to investigating Obama's true connections with such figures as William Ayers and Jeremiah Wright, the people who voted for Obama are going to be upset.
Seated alongside Sykes was a member of the "elite mainstream media," Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel columnist Patrick McIlheran. Sykes didn't blame McIlheran directly, but he should have.
Because the best McIlheran has been able to come up with are hyperlinks to the crazed "Corner" bloggers at National Review Online and his own unsupported ditherings that Ayers and Obama are intellectual soulmates of identically radical disposition.
So long as McIlheran isn't out applying shoe leather to the pavement in Chicago, which is only an hour's drive from his office, he's just as responsible as anybody for Charlie Sykes's sad disappointments.
Seated alongside Sykes was a member of the "elite mainstream media," Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel columnist Patrick McIlheran. Sykes didn't blame McIlheran directly, but he should have.
Because the best McIlheran has been able to come up with are hyperlinks to the crazed "Corner" bloggers at National Review Online and his own unsupported ditherings that Ayers and Obama are intellectual soulmates of identically radical disposition.
So long as McIlheran isn't out applying shoe leather to the pavement in Chicago, which is only an hour's drive from his office, he's just as responsible as anybody for Charlie Sykes's sad disappointments.
May 3, 2008
The J-S's farcical featury tour
Of the Quesosphere (thanks to whomever I stole that from).
While it somehow managed a score with its citation to Mike Mathias's excellent, well-focused piece here, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel's weekend Crossroads feature "Best of the Wisconsin Blogs" continues in its ill-considered proclivity.
Semi-coherent local radio shouting meathead Charlie Sykes "wins" Best of the Blogs with a five-sentence contribution (that's Sykes's entire blog entry — and the first of the five sentences is a cliché so grotesque even pro wrestling's abandoned it: "It's on.") containing the most uninformative, unenlightening, and downright pedestrian observation of the Barack Obama-Jeremiah Wright "controversy" that couldn't be imagined.
Meanwhile, to grab just one example, Mike Plaisted throws down this feisty and typically well-written number, inspiring a lengthy comment thread featuring some of the higher quality back-and-forth to be found 'round these parts yet Charlie Sykes, whose own blog consists of 99% other people's work (except reproduced in all-italics — it's even typographically annoying), gets the accolade: "Best of."
And not Jim Bouman's digital slide show/reportage tour of Pabst Farms (the photo captions alone are "Best of" material).
At least if the J-S selection committee had an intentional sense of humor, it would have honored Charlie Sykes for this April 28 howler:
Presumably the J-S picks two blogs from the "left" and two from the "right" for its "Best of" edition and on reflection it isn't so surprising that its potential field of nominees in the latter category is slim.
But why on Earth Charlie Sykes would even qualify as a Wisconsin blogger at all is a mystery and, more importantly, with so many thoughtful and talented writers out here, that the J-S would favor a blatantly self-referential corporate plug rather than acknowledge the existence of dedicated, independent local writers is very telling.
Next thing you know, a member of the Journal-Sentinel's editorial board will be making regular appearances on Sunday INCITE!
The best blogs are far too piquant for JRN HQ anyway. It's in the business of journalism, where journalism never lists the ship.
While it somehow managed a score with its citation to Mike Mathias's excellent, well-focused piece here, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel's weekend Crossroads feature "Best of the Wisconsin Blogs" continues in its ill-considered proclivity.
Semi-coherent local radio shouting meathead Charlie Sykes "wins" Best of the Blogs with a five-sentence contribution (that's Sykes's entire blog entry — and the first of the five sentences is a cliché so grotesque even pro wrestling's abandoned it: "It's on.") containing the most uninformative, unenlightening, and downright pedestrian observation of the Barack Obama-Jeremiah Wright "controversy" that couldn't be imagined.
Meanwhile, to grab just one example, Mike Plaisted throws down this feisty and typically well-written number, inspiring a lengthy comment thread featuring some of the higher quality back-and-forth to be found 'round these parts yet Charlie Sykes, whose own blog consists of 99% other people's work (except reproduced in all-italics — it's even typographically annoying), gets the accolade: "Best of."
And not Jim Bouman's digital slide show/reportage tour of Pabst Farms (the photo captions alone are "Best of" material).
At least if the J-S selection committee had an intentional sense of humor, it would have honored Charlie Sykes for this April 28 howler:
Went to see Ben Stein's new movie "Expelled," yesterday. Powerful, provocative, and definitely worth a view.Oh definitely, if you're into bullshit and lies and the embarrassing spectacle of Ben Stein blaming Charles Darwin for the Nazi Holocaust.
Presumably the J-S picks two blogs from the "left" and two from the "right" for its "Best of" edition and on reflection it isn't so surprising that its potential field of nominees in the latter category is slim.
But why on Earth Charlie Sykes would even qualify as a Wisconsin blogger at all is a mystery and, more importantly, with so many thoughtful and talented writers out here, that the J-S would favor a blatantly self-referential corporate plug rather than acknowledge the existence of dedicated, independent local writers is very telling.
Next thing you know, a member of the Journal-Sentinel's editorial board will be making regular appearances on Sunday INCITE!
The best blogs are far too piquant for JRN HQ anyway. It's in the business of journalism, where journalism never lists the ship.
In Re:
blogosphere,
wisconsin
March 24, 2008
Themes from The Blogfather
Sung to the tune of Speak Softly, Love:
As I mentioned yesterday, Marquette Law Professor Rick Esenberg invited us all to view his appearance on Milwaukee squawker Charlie Sykes's teevee program, Sunday INCITE! It's with great regret I now announce that I couldn't stand more than nine minutes of the show and switched back to the eminently more edifying Bret Michaels: Rock of Love.
Not because of Esenberg, mind you, although his efforts to equate the campaign of Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Louis Butler with that of Burnett County Judge Mike Gableman nearly made me spit my juice all over the copy of The Anarchist Cookbook* on my coffee table. More on that in another post.
Charles J. Sykes, in short, is a buffoon, a performing ape. During the mercifully brief discussion of the Supreme Court election, Sykes managed to refer to Gableman as "Michael Gableman" or "Mike Gableman." But Butler may only be "Loophole Louie." Charming.
First of all, Louis is pronounced like "Lewis." Justice Butler earned the nickname during his days as a State public defender. It's a lawyers' joke, an affectionate moniker containing a playfully needling element. More importantly, it's a compliment to Butler's skills as an attorney, which further contributes to Sykes's inadvertent clownishness that he insists on using it.
Years ago, when scientists, notably the astronomer Edwin Hubble, first observed that the universe is expanding, the resultant set of inferences earned the derision of Fred Hoyle, a British physicist who scornfully dubbed them the "Big Bang" theory. Bemused astronomers, knowing full well that Hoyle's characterization was meant as a put-down, adopted the term and now, of course, Hoyle has been decidedly proven wrong.
A similar principle inheres in Butler's ancient nickname which he earned, incidentally, 25 years ago. Sykes simply needs to get over it. Either that or put up some evidence that Butler has adjudicated like a public defender during his 16 years as a judge (longer than Gableman has been a lawyer), which is quite obviously why Sykes continues to use the nickname. Needless to say, Sykes, nor anyone else, is going to come up with that evidence.
However, since getting over it requires the condition precedent of Sykes getting over himself, it's not going to happen. In the meantime, everybody should just point and laugh at him, because obviously that's what he wants. What other explanation can there be?
Of course there are many other reasons to point and laugh at Sykes. He provided yet another yesterday, responding to an item by Daniel Bice in the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. It seems that a lawyer called John O'Connor, who is involved in a case currently before the State Supreme Court, recently donated to Butler's campaign.
Bice thinks this is "a funny thing," partly because Justice Butler recently took the extraordinary step of disclosing the information where campaign contributions came from parties with business before the court. It's funny, alright, but not for the reason Bice is implying. It's funny because of why O'Connor was moved to make the contributions:
Incidentally, Gableman's campaign website, under "Endorsements," still looks like this, as of this morning, despite DA Bauer's letter having appeared in print five days ago:

Sykes's response to Bice's item is also funny: "Justice for sale?" is the headline at Sykes's "blog," without the slightest hint of evidence as to whether the question is even called for, let alone the clear suggestion of impropriety on the part of Justice Butler. That headline, by the way, is Sykes's sole contribution to the discussion. Despite this, Sykes has earned his own nickname, "the blogfather," from some of his fawning acolytes on the right.
Why this is is a bit of a mystery, since Sykes's blog contains almost entirely copy-and-paste jobs from other blogs and the occasional YouTube clip of scantily-clad, booty-shaking females. (If Sykes does provide any meaningful public service at all, it's those.)
If you aren't pointing and laughing yet, I'll leave you with an example of Sykes's legal acumen, the substance of which practically precludes him from commenting on this Supreme Court race at all, except that would deprive us of grist for the comedy mill, and that's not such a good thing.
Some time ago at this blog, I discussed in some detail the case of State v. Knapp, which at one point was a centerpiece of the Gableman campaign. It appears to have been long since abandoned, perhaps because portrayals of the case by Gableman and his supporters were so embarrassingly misbegotten and just plain wrong.
In any event, Justice Butler himself discusses State v. Knapp during his interview with the Journal-Sentinel editorial board, which can be viewed by following this link. (It's excellent, by the way.)
I can't say whether J-S editorial board member Patrick McIlheran nodded off during that discussion too but if he did, he missed some good stuff. I say that because Butler's emphasis on the pertinent constitutional questions raised in Knapp was an almost direct reading of my original blog post. I flatter myself unwarrantedly to suggest that Justice Butler reads this blog — which I doubt — because, obviously, he wrote the opinion in Knapp.
Anyway, here's what Sykes had to say about Knapp (he does write his own stuff occasionally, in between shouting on the radio, just not at his blog):
Charlie Sykes, I'm told, is actually taken seriously among a certain local demographic, which is as much a mystery to me as was initially the red-shift of galaxies to Edwin Hubble. Hubble eventually figured it out, but I remain at a loss to explain Sykes's apparent popularity, aside from as, of course, an occasionally entertaining performing primate.
* Note to the DHS: That's a joke; living as I do a short skip from Taco Bell, I have no need for any cookbooks at all.
Squawk loudly, Sykes, I hold my sides before you speak— with sincere apologies to Larry Kusic and Nino Rota
We hear your words, the violent shakes reaching their peak
You're in your world
We rest assured
Sharing hip musings and the cant of Esenberg
As I mentioned yesterday, Marquette Law Professor Rick Esenberg invited us all to view his appearance on Milwaukee squawker Charlie Sykes's teevee program, Sunday INCITE! It's with great regret I now announce that I couldn't stand more than nine minutes of the show and switched back to the eminently more edifying Bret Michaels: Rock of Love.
Not because of Esenberg, mind you, although his efforts to equate the campaign of Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice Louis Butler with that of Burnett County Judge Mike Gableman nearly made me spit my juice all over the copy of The Anarchist Cookbook* on my coffee table. More on that in another post.
Charles J. Sykes, in short, is a buffoon, a performing ape. During the mercifully brief discussion of the Supreme Court election, Sykes managed to refer to Gableman as "Michael Gableman" or "Mike Gableman." But Butler may only be "Loophole Louie." Charming.
First of all, Louis is pronounced like "Lewis." Justice Butler earned the nickname during his days as a State public defender. It's a lawyers' joke, an affectionate moniker containing a playfully needling element. More importantly, it's a compliment to Butler's skills as an attorney, which further contributes to Sykes's inadvertent clownishness that he insists on using it.
Years ago, when scientists, notably the astronomer Edwin Hubble, first observed that the universe is expanding, the resultant set of inferences earned the derision of Fred Hoyle, a British physicist who scornfully dubbed them the "Big Bang" theory. Bemused astronomers, knowing full well that Hoyle's characterization was meant as a put-down, adopted the term and now, of course, Hoyle has been decidedly proven wrong.
A similar principle inheres in Butler's ancient nickname which he earned, incidentally, 25 years ago. Sykes simply needs to get over it. Either that or put up some evidence that Butler has adjudicated like a public defender during his 16 years as a judge (longer than Gableman has been a lawyer), which is quite obviously why Sykes continues to use the nickname. Needless to say, Sykes, nor anyone else, is going to come up with that evidence.
However, since getting over it requires the condition precedent of Sykes getting over himself, it's not going to happen. In the meantime, everybody should just point and laugh at him, because obviously that's what he wants. What other explanation can there be?
Of course there are many other reasons to point and laugh at Sykes. He provided yet another yesterday, responding to an item by Daniel Bice in the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. It seems that a lawyer called John O'Connor, who is involved in a case currently before the State Supreme Court, recently donated to Butler's campaign.
Bice thinks this is "a funny thing," partly because Justice Butler recently took the extraordinary step of disclosing the information where campaign contributions came from parties with business before the court. It's funny, alright, but not for the reason Bice is implying. It's funny because of why O'Connor was moved to make the contributions:
O'Connor said the donations had nothing to do with his case. He said he gave after pro-Gableman ads "pissed me off beyond description."Who can blame him for that? It seems like an appropriate response to me, especially in light of our good friend, Dodge County District Attorney Steven G. Bauer's manifestly well considered decision to withdraw his endorsement for Mike Gableman who, as far as I'm concerned, can continue pissing lawyers off to his heart's content, if these are the effects.
Incidentally, Gableman's campaign website, under "Endorsements," still looks like this, as of this morning, despite DA Bauer's letter having appeared in print five days ago:

Sykes's response to Bice's item is also funny: "Justice for sale?" is the headline at Sykes's "blog," without the slightest hint of evidence as to whether the question is even called for, let alone the clear suggestion of impropriety on the part of Justice Butler. That headline, by the way, is Sykes's sole contribution to the discussion. Despite this, Sykes has earned his own nickname, "the blogfather," from some of his fawning acolytes on the right.
Why this is is a bit of a mystery, since Sykes's blog contains almost entirely copy-and-paste jobs from other blogs and the occasional YouTube clip of scantily-clad, booty-shaking females. (If Sykes does provide any meaningful public service at all, it's those.)
If you aren't pointing and laughing yet, I'll leave you with an example of Sykes's legal acumen, the substance of which practically precludes him from commenting on this Supreme Court race at all, except that would deprive us of grist for the comedy mill, and that's not such a good thing.
Some time ago at this blog, I discussed in some detail the case of State v. Knapp, which at one point was a centerpiece of the Gableman campaign. It appears to have been long since abandoned, perhaps because portrayals of the case by Gableman and his supporters were so embarrassingly misbegotten and just plain wrong.
In any event, Justice Butler himself discusses State v. Knapp during his interview with the Journal-Sentinel editorial board, which can be viewed by following this link. (It's excellent, by the way.)
I can't say whether J-S editorial board member Patrick McIlheran nodded off during that discussion too but if he did, he missed some good stuff. I say that because Butler's emphasis on the pertinent constitutional questions raised in Knapp was an almost direct reading of my original blog post. I flatter myself unwarrantedly to suggest that Justice Butler reads this blog — which I doubt — because, obviously, he wrote the opinion in Knapp.
Anyway, here's what Sykes had to say about Knapp (he does write his own stuff occasionally, in between shouting on the radio, just not at his blog):
What stunned the dissenters and many court watchers, however, was the court’s decision to ignore the specific decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in the case before it.Now this is beyond merely comical, it's demonstrably idiotic, and if you want to know why, go and read my original post. Or, obviously, watch the Butler interview (which you should do anyway).
Charlie Sykes, I'm told, is actually taken seriously among a certain local demographic, which is as much a mystery to me as was initially the red-shift of galaxies to Edwin Hubble. Hubble eventually figured it out, but I remain at a loss to explain Sykes's apparent popularity, aside from as, of course, an occasionally entertaining performing primate.
* Note to the DHS: That's a joke; living as I do a short skip from Taco Bell, I have no need for any cookbooks at all.
March 23, 2008
A bit of Sunday insight
Marquette Law Professor Rick Esenberg reminds us that he'll be appearing today on Sunday Incite, the morning show hosted by Milwaukee squawking head Charles J. Sykes. So I thought I'd rise at stupid o'clock just in case Prof. Esenberg decides to check in with his favorite blogger first, and just in case the topic of the Wisconsin Supreme Court presents itself to Sykes & Co.If both of those premises are satisfied, then perhaps Prof. Esenberg might be kind enough to keep the following thoughts in mind as he engages the said topic. I respect Prof. Esenberg, except he's got some decidedly unsavory friends. But whatever. Here's what he wrote about your humble correspondent last night:
[illusory tenant] wants to make [Louis Butler] look "good" in the sense of not [favoring criminal defendants].Not exactly. Louis Butler does not need me, or anyone else, to make him look good. I entertain no such self-serving presumptions. In fact, it was never even my intent at all to follow this election campaign as closely as I have. However, beginning in November, when Burnett County Judge Mike Gableman first started circulating his facile misrepresentations of the law, I began to take notice.
As for "favoring criminal defendants," that whole idea, which Gableman and his deep pocketed supporters are attempting to make the central issue over — of all things — a seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, is itself facile and misleading.
It may be a slogan suitable to a campaign for district attorney, but practically ridiculous in the present context, considering the functions of the State's highest appellate court, which outright rejects the overwhelming majority of criminal appeals in the first place.
And Esenberg knows as well as anyone just how facile and misleading it is. The Gableman campaign and its surrogates are orchestrating a farce of the lowest order on the people of Wisconsin, if not the country: witness the attention this campaign is lately getting from Newsweek.
Look at Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce, Gableman's biggest supporter in terms of resources, which actually has the unmitigated temerity to portray the Confrontation Clause of the Sixth Amendment as a "needless technicality." How is one to react to that? With a combination of riotous laughter and abject horror, I should think. A provision of the Bill of Rights ... a needless technicality.
I don't know about Esenberg, who, let us not forget, has lent his considerable acumen to the WMC's campaign against Louis Butler, but I beg to differ. In my view, the U.S. Constitution is the product and expression of sheer political and legal genius, and it's practically impossible to overstate its importance.
I can barely believe my eyes, to see it reduced to a needless technicality. Every single person in this country should rightly be appalled at WMC's downright anti-American propaganda.
Let me also be clear in reiterating that this is a campaign against Louis Butler, and not a campaign in favor of Mike Gableman. Gableman, who has now had nearly six months to present himself and his ideas, remains essentially a cipher. We know very little about him. We have no idea whether he's even read a decision of the Wisconsin Supreme Court, let alone that he even understands what the job he's seeking entails.
In my considered opinion, the relatively little he has presented mitigates strongly against either proposition.
Have any of the anti-Butler forces even read Butler's dissent in State v. Jensen? It's a pretty impressive piece of work, by any standards, and tightly reasoned. Butler traces the history of the Confrontation Clause back to the 16th century, a reminder of the protections against the Crown that became embodied in the United States Constitution, the envy of the world. It's like reading the work of another famous son of Milwaukee, Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist of Shorewood High, the "historian" of the U.S. Supreme Court.
I read it a long time ago and as a matter of fact it was the subject of my very first post on this campaign back in December, discussing how Butler's approach exemplifies both narrow textualism and original intent, two doctrines of constitutional interpretation to which political conservatives normally proclaim undying devotion.
Now suddenly it's "needless technicalities"? How in the world can anybody take Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce seriously?
Please excuse my French, but just how fucking stupid do they think we are? I submit that we are far, far from stupid, and as such we need to summarily reject their disingenuous ploys, along with their obscure, bought-and-paid-for candidate, Mike Gableman.
Leave him be, where he can continue to protect the residents of Burnett County, and "preside over" their thousands of uncontested traffic tickets. Because he's clearly not ready for prime time.
Moreover, when the relatively conservative U.S. Supreme Court affirms and vindicates Justice Butler's Jensen dissent in Giles v. California later this year, it will be a proud day not only for Butler, but for all Wisconsinites. If you forget about it by then, fear not, I'll be sure to remind y'all.
As for Jessica McBride and her thoughtless enabler at the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel, Patrick McIlheran, my criticism of them has been based in what is their demonstrably irresponsible journalism. Not only is it clear now that McBride didn't even understand the meaning of the numbers at the heart of the documents she has been working feverishly to defame Justice Butler with, but McIlheran didn't make the slightest effort to understand either.
Instead, they rushed headlong to announce their preordained conclusions, in this case, that a sitting Justice of the Wisconsin Supreme Court is a liar. Can the practice of alleged journalism get any lower? Maybe, but not by much.
One final thought. I have accused Gableman of deliberately misrepresenting the law. The reason for that is because I have no other choice. I have shown, on many occasions, with evidence, how he is misrepresenting the law. And I'm not done, either. So have others, most recently in the commentary concerning his utterly disgraceful television spot. That leaves the question of whether he is doing it deliberately or inadvertently.
If the latter, then Gableman is incompetent. That is, unworthy and unsuited to the position he seeks. By definition. But I am not calling him incompetent, for obvious reasons. Because I do know the law.
That leaves deliberate misrepresentation. And deliberate misrepresentation of the law is what Gableman and his supporters are up to, in their campaign to defame Louis Butler. It seems to me one of the reasons — perhaps the only reason — that the Gableman campaign is doing this is because he can't run on his own merits and that is because, compared to Louis Butler, he has very few.
Ultimately, whether deliberate — as opposed to inadvertent — misrepresentation of the law makes Gableman more or less unworthy or unsuitable for the Wisconsin Supreme Court is a pretty close call, I must say.
Is this really the individual that the people of Wisconsin should choose to install on the highest court in their State, thereby replacing someone who's been a judge longer than Gableman has been a lawyer? I should certainly hope not.
And while he'll probably never admit to it, I bet that — "in his heart," as they say — Esenberg agrees with much of the foregoing.
Happy Easter.
March 17, 2008
The blogfather gets a clue?
A guy on a blog says local conservative radio yelper Charlie Sykes called Burnett County Judge Michael Gableman's recent teevee spot "despicable." I'm in no position to verify this because three minutes of Sykes's show was about all I could stand one time.
The blog commenter made this remark last night, but I hear tell from people who monitor Sykes's own teevee spot Sunday Incite — bless their hearts; talk about taking one for the team — that Milwaukee's own King of All Media only made some superficial nod to the campaign advertising generally being "over the line."
Not that I give a rat's left nut what Charlie Sykes thinks or says, but evidently a lot of people do, and if he specifically condemned Gableman's tribute to the State Supreme Court's character and fitness guidelines, then I suppose that might be significant.
Confirm or deny. I know about 450 of Sykes's lemmings invaded this blog one day, so maybe two or three of them are still lurking about.
The blog commenter made this remark last night, but I hear tell from people who monitor Sykes's own teevee spot Sunday Incite — bless their hearts; talk about taking one for the team — that Milwaukee's own King of All Media only made some superficial nod to the campaign advertising generally being "over the line."
Not that I give a rat's left nut what Charlie Sykes thinks or says, but evidently a lot of people do, and if he specifically condemned Gableman's tribute to the State Supreme Court's character and fitness guidelines, then I suppose that might be significant.
Confirm or deny. I know about 450 of Sykes's lemmings invaded this blog one day, so maybe two or three of them are still lurking about.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)