Showing posts sorted by date for query Lueders. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query Lueders. Sort by relevance Show all posts

May 7, 2012

Walker has less than a month to create 250K jobs

Bill Lueders: Scooter's vanishing acts

"By the end of his term," June 5, "God willing," as he is fond of saying.*

* I'd mention that al-Qaeda also punctuates its press releases with this mini-prayer, but I'm mindful of the Journal-Sentinel's admonitions.

January 11, 2012

The lawyer in question was Rich Esenberg

Hilarious:
[Dr. Ernie Pelegrino] cited as authority for this professor Scott Idleman of Marquette University Law School, as quoted during an interview on a local right-wing talk show. I have had a telephone conference with Idleman, who indicated he did not appear on that radio show, does not agree with these assertions, and would not comment on legal ethics, which he does not teach.* Idleman was concerned enough about this matter that he did some research to discover that the lawyer in question was in all probability Rich Esenberg, a former part-time instructor at Marquette. — from the (Madison) Capital Times mailbag
Scott Idleman happens to be a fine fellow and a personal hero of mine.

* Neither does Esenberg, but try telling that to Journal Communications, Inc. That respondent "Peppercorn" Gableman's arrangement with Michael Best & Friedrich is commonplace is an utterly fatuous claim. It ain't.

The very action Gableman faced is rare, let alone his fee arrangement, which is commonplace only in completely different circumstances, where its contractual benefits inhere to plaintiffs, and not to defendants.

Incidentally I notice this column by Bill Lueders is making the rounds in republication today. When Eric McLeod told the Journal-Sentinel that Gableman paid his bill, he could have meant the bill for photocopying.

January 5, 2012

Did "Peppercorn" Gableman's attorney also lie?

Bill Lueders wants to know:
"[Michael Best & Friedrich LLP partner Eric M.] McLeod said Gableman had a standard billing agreement with the law firm and has paid that bill" [emphasis added].
Mr. McLeod was personally sanctioned by a federal court on Tuesday.

All this must be doing wonders for MB&F's reputation, aina?

August 30, 2011

"The only thing stupid here is Althouse's column."

Bruce Murphy is a little late to the party, but better late than never:
Bill Lueders had three off-the-record sources telling him that Justice Prosser "allegedly grabbed fellow justice by the neck," as the headline of his story noted. And as we now know from Justice Prosser, he had both hands on Justice Bradley’s neck.
Yes, well, try telling that to Mr. Althouse.

Then of course there was this guy too.

August 27, 2011

Trollicane Meade makes blogfall

Newsflash: Bill Lueders got tooled. And illusory tenant is - allegedly - his willing bitch.
What an internets honor.

Yet Lueders was vindicated and his detractors look the fools.

(And I am hardly Bill Lueders's bitch, for the record.)

June 28, 2011

How many sharks can one Shark jump?

Clearly, an infinite amount.

Sometimes I swear WisOpinion.com, the local aggregator of Wisconsin's "opinion leaders," links to stuff just for giggles, much like Jerry Falwell used to get invited on the Sunday morning chat shows so the producers and news editors could chuckle at him. Case in point, Rick Esenberg's pretend lament at the state of affairs on the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

Recall that Bill Lueders broke the story Saturday morning. None of Lueders's sources were named, but he obviously had them. By Saturday evening, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel had managed to obtain a statement from Ann Walsh Bradley, a justice of the Wisconsin Supreme Court, confirming the substantive details of Lueders's story. The Journal-Sentinel also obtained a statement from the accused, David Prosser, that did not deny some physical altercation had taken place, but rather simply varied from the perspective of Justice Bradley's account.

Peake fantasy

Furthermore the Journal-Sentinel obtained statements from two anonymous sources — who remain anonymous as of this writing — neither of which deny some physical altercation but, as does Prosser, present a different perspective of the alleged altercation. So what does Rick Esenberg, an actual professor of the law, make of all this?

Well, first of all, he denounces Lueders for "an embarrassingly bad piece of work" despite the fact that Lueders's report was confirmed by a justice of the Supreme Court who went on the record to confirm it.

What's embarrassing or bad about it exactly, he doesn't deign to reveal, but the professor's unsupported assertions suit perfectly the obfuscatory narrative Esenberg and his fellow travelers are seeking to forward.

And despite even the fact of Justice Bradley's affirmations, Esenberg pronounces her allegations "fantastical," conveniently overlooking Justice Prosser's self-admitted history of aggressiveness toward Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson, whom he had previously threatened to "destroy," and who is relatively small in stature and who is nearly a decade the elder of Prosser. Moreover Bradley had warned against Prosser's behavior in emails she released to a Journal-Sentinel reporter months ago.*

Now all of a sudden the latest in an apparent pattern of reckless and intemperate behavior is "fantastical," like a Mervyn Peake novel.

Justice/Gableman

But what is most remarkable — outrageous, really — about Esenberg's own reckless missive is that he suggests the Wisconsin Judicial Commission back off from carrying through its investigation:
[T]he worst thing, I think, would be to frustrate the will of the voters by the imposition of discipline based upon controverted allegations. That would smack of a coup. It would undermine the legitimacy of the Court. [**]
Let's review a couple of things here.

Justice Prosser would be the third consecutive Wisconsin Supreme Court justice subject to an investigation by the Wisconsin Judicial Commission, all of them self-advertised "conservatives," and all of them members of the court that just two weeks ago abandoned bedrock principles of legal procedure, invented from whole cloth a novel fabrication of the court's jurisdictional authority, imported into its written order and opinions alleged facts that were never even mentioned by any party or court as the case wended its way toward the Michael/Gableman Four, and for all intents and purposes untenably reprimanded a careful, review-proven conservative circuit judge for — ironically — supposedly abusing her authority, a reprimand meted out by the same court that had just moments before whipped into existence its own purported authority.

The allegations Esenberg is talking about are those of Justice Bradley who, it bears again repeating, went on the record to confirm the pertinent details of Lueders's "embarrassingly bad" report. And the "controversions" Esenberg is talking about are those anonymous sources quoted by the Journal Communications, Inc. flagship daily newspaper.

Blinka job safe

Not only does Esenberg accord the latter equal weight, he accords them such countervailing authority that, Esenberg reasons, they should not only drive the Wisconsin Judicial Commission's investigation but in fact discourage the Commission from proceeding. All one might say to that is, thank gods Esenberg is not teaching the law of evidence over there.

Esenberg's "will of the voters," it needs also to be recalled, is Justice Prosser's 0.46% margin of victory over challenger JoAnne Kloppenburg, who for her part realized double-digit (not double-decimal point) surges in popular support between February's primary contest and the April 5 general election — especially in the State's most conservative counties.

Thus would it "smack of a coup" were the Wisconsin Judicial Commission, which is charged by State statute to investigate unprofessional behavior among the State judiciary, to pursue its mandated obligations.

It's quite the amazing performance by Rick Esenberg, who has a long and fairly well documented history of amazing performances. It's . . .


Ta Da! Ol' Prof. Rick is right about one thing though:
Lawyers have been worried about the divisions on the Court [**] for some time now. ... No one likes to say too much about it in public for fear of alienating the people who may decide their clients' matters.
Oh, but I'm sure they would like to say plenty about it, and what they would mostly say Esenberg probably wouldn't want to hear. Because the current divisions on the court are directly traceable to Mike Gableman, who none other than Rick Esenberg championed by defending some of the most disgraceful attacks on former Justice Louis Butler's reputation, character, and professionalism, and whose own then-research assistant's gibberish Esenberg is still publishing at the Marquette LS faculty blog.

Esenberg's "worried lawyers" ain't going to forget. It's one thing to get along — and a good thing — but it's quite another to abandon principles because some partisan ideologue is boo-hooing like a sad crocodile.

Your humble correspondent may not be the disinterested academic ivory tower dweller Rick Esenberg is presented as by Journal Communications, Inc.'s panoply of media dispensaries but I surely do know that much.

* There was some considerable right-wing pearls-clutching over Justice Bradley's handing over the emails to the reporter. However, go have a look in the WisconsinEye.org video archives for the court's open administrative conferences and you will find both Justices Prosser and Roggensack releasing sheafs of interchambers emails to the press.

The political right's shameless hypocrisy is quite the spectacle to behold.

** You do not capitalize court here. Capitalizing court here would be a signal for the United State Supreme Court. This from a professor of law.

June 27, 2011

Ann Althouse, like Justice Prosser, sniffs a turd

According to alleged professor of law Ann Althouse, Bill Lueders, who broke the story Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice David Prosser allegedly seized a colleague, Justice Ann Walsh Bradley, by the neck with both hands, Governor Scott Walker's momentous budget-singing ceremony "was overshadowed by the gigantic turd Lueders felt moved to drop at exactly that moment." Althouse seems hell-bent on discrediting Lueders's reporting, despite the fact Justice Bradley herself has since affirmed it.

Most rational actors would reverse course at that point.

Perhaps Althouse is too demure to outright call Justice Bradley a liar and instead has been busying herself with attempting to discredit Lueders's confirmed reporting and failing rather spectacularly at that project.*

The alleged law professor's scatological metaphor is especially entertaining when one recalls Prosser's election-time fauxtrage at coming upon a reader post at Supreme Court candidate JoAnne Kloppenburg's Facebook, which read, "Stop the turd, vote Kloppenburg."

"Now, am I the turd?," Justice Prosser had actually inquired.

Apparently so, albeit not Althouse's "gigantic turd," as Althouse also assures us Justice Bradley is "significantly larger" than Justice Prosser.

I've heard students at the University of Wisconsin Law School go out of their way to avoid enrolling in Althouse's classes. That's not surprising.

* WPRI's Christian Schneider lauds Althouse for doing "yeoman's work."

eta 01: Fortunately for the rest of us Ann Althouse is not in charge of the Dane County Sheriff's Office. Justice Bradley's allegations may constitute a felony charge. They need to be taken seriously, contra the alleged professor of law's wild and frivolously idiotic speculations.

eta 02: As they are taken by the Wisconsin Judicial Commission.

As mentioned here previously, the Supreme Court is charged with overseeing the ethical behavior and education of the State's attorneys, an authority that is becoming less and less possible to take seriously.

And I don't believe it was ever possible to take Ann Althouse seriously.

May 31, 2011

No ethics complaint forthcoming for Justice Prosser

In the Isthmus, Bill Lueders noted the other day that former Wisconsin Supreme Court justice Donald Steinmetz filed an ethics complaint with the Office of Lawyer Regulation against Joel Winnig, the Madison attorney who lost to JoAnne Kloppenburg in the February primary.

Steinmetz is upset Winnig referred to Mike Gableman as "a cancer on the body politic" who "continues to pollute the Wisconsin Supreme Court." (This space strongly condemned the remarks as "not helpful.")

It may be recalled that Gableman himself was found in late 2009 by a three-judge panel to have violated two separate provisions of the State code of judicial ethics for his antics in the 2008 Supreme Court election.

Joel Winnig's harsh comments are pure opinion, obviously. On the other hand, what to make of Justice David Prosser's rejoinder:
"I think Joel has been smoking some of the stuff he wants to legalize," Prosser said, referring to Winnig's position on marijuana.
Isn't Justice Prosser accusing Joel Winnig of committing a crime? That's damaging to Winnig's reputation, even if Justice Prosser was kidding.

So where is the OLR ethics complaint against Justice Prosser?

Fair's fair.

April 15, 2011

The strange case of Kilkenny v. Sumi

Oy vey, the things you find on WisOpinion sometimes.*

Top conservative blogger Cindy Kilkenny of Brookfield, Waukesha Co., Wisconsin reckons she's pulled one over on Dane County Circuit Judge Maryann Sumi. "Sumi continues to make up the law as she goes along," announces Kilkenny. This is not gonna end well for CK.

The "fairly conservative" blogger Kilkenny objects to a passage in Judge Sumi's ruling yesterday in Kathleen Falk v. Fitzwalkerstan,** which is a separate action from the ongoing Ozanne v. Fitzgerald, the latter being much discussed at this here space and elsewhere. For it was in Ozanne that Judge Sumi issued her celebrated (and [fairly] conservatively reasoned) temporary restraining order against the Fitz Van Walker consortium's twilight union-smashing shenanigans.

Judge Sumi (bestest judge name evar) wrote on April 14:
[§§] 19.97(2) and (3), Wis. Stats., grant the circuit court express authority to void action taken in violation of the open meetings law and to issue injunctive relief.
Bold Kilkenny's (in at least two equally clear senses of the word bold).

The "authority to void action" comes from § 19.97(3), whereas the "authority ... to issue injunctive relief" comes from § 19.97(2). (Note well the "and" in "and to issue injunctive relief." Kilkenny even bolded it for you.) While Judge Sumi has issued (temporary) injunctive relief in accordance with § 19.97(2), she is some ways away from "void[ing] action taken in violation of the open meetings law," as the latter remedy is the one requested at the heart of Ozanne v. Fitzgerald and Judge Sumi has yet to adjudicate the merits of Ozanne's lawsuit and therefore obviously no judgment has been entered in adjudication.

Thus there is no judgment in the following sense:
However, any judgment declaring such action void shall not be entered unless the court finds, under the facts of the particular case, that the public interest in the enforcement of this subchapter outweighs any public interest which there may be in sustaining the validity of the action taken.
That's from § 19.97(3). Judge Sumi hasn't made any such judgment, so Kilkenny's assertions are both premature and totally irrelevant. I have no idea whether Cindy Kilkenny would be interested in retracting her bold "Sumi continues to make up the law as she goes along" announcement, but it certainly is false and borders on the comic.***

In fact I might rank it right up there with Gawker's legal advice to Sarah Palin. To paraphrase Judge Sumi, the defendants could have saved everyone a lot of time and trouble if they just revoted the bill.

Likewise, top WaukCo. conservative blogger Cindy Kilkenny could have just asked me. I've already been "fairly" accommodating.

* Or, the sights you see when you have no gun, as my dear departed granny (who never fired a gun in her long life) was fond of saying.

** But seriously folks, Dane County v. State of Wisconsin.

*** And it's probably too late anyways, since it's been immortalized at and by the WisOpinion.com aggregator.

eta: Cindy Kilkenny responds. But obviously I have never, ever once said or suggested any of those things. If I didn't think anybody but a "liberal elitist" would understand, then why would I try to explain it?

Take issue with the explanations, not some dreamed-up chimeras.

What motivated this post in the first place is the incredibly ill-informed — and vicious, as Bill Lueders enumerated — commentary about Judge Sumi's deliberations. Attempting to correct the public record has nothing to do with "liberal elitism" and I've tried to limn the transgressions even when committed by "conservative elitists."

(The latter example being legalist arrogance of the lowest order. Your correspondent can't even aspire to that degree of superciliousness.)

The press certainly won't do it, so somebody has to. Indeed, from where I sit, the press actively encourages the ill-informedness.

April 14, 2011

Judge Sumi gets mail

Bill Lueders collects it. And it's really, really, appallingly ignorant.

The fact of the matter is, Dane County Circuit Judge Maryann Sumi is on firm legal ground, and is following very conservative principles of statutory and constitutional construction. Failing a higher court's ruling according to the most circuitously reasoned of procedural arcana, there seems to me no way that Judge Sumi's temporary restraining order in Ozanne v. Fitzgerald can be vacated without finding the Wisconsin Open Meetings Law is itself unconstitutional.

March 14, 2011

Ann Althouse's legal research 101

Ruh roh: Inexplicably popular Wisconsin blogger/reported professor of law Ann Althouse is in horrified semi-dudgeon over a remark made by State Supreme Court candidate JoAnne Kloppenburg:
At a forum at the Waukesha County Courthouse [Thursday]:
"Justice Prosser has sent a clear message that he will favor the agenda of Gov. (Scott) Walker and the Republican Legislature," Kloppenburg said. "I will apply the law to the facts of the cases before me and decide them without prejudice."
What is her basis for attributing a "clear message" like that to Prosser? If she doesn't have a solid basis for that statement — and I can't see what it is — how is that supposed to jibe with her self-image as a dutiful applicant of law to fact?
Ever the keen observer, Prof. Althouse* proceeds to link to a column by the Isthmus's Bill Lueders which clearly describes Kloppenburg's "basis" and further provides Kloppenburg's own statement:
In a press release on 12/8/2010, the Prosser Campaign promised that returning the incumbent to the bench would "[protect] the conservative judicial majority" on the Court which would then be able to "act as a common sense compliment [sic] to both the new administration and legislature."
Twice, right there in Althouse's own link, yet: "I can't see what it is."

It's old news anyway.

Pro Tip: Read own links before engaging the fauxtrage.

* That comments thread is hilarious.

August 27, 2010

Bill Lueders gets up on right side of bed

Why in the world is Bill Lueders complaining about Russ Feingold's reaction to Fox News/Republican/Tea candidate Ron Johnson's wanting to treat firearms "like we license cars and stuff"?

More importantly, how about Ron Johnson acknowledging that his retooled stance — following on the heels and toes of podiatric extraction — as practically a Second Amendment absolutist wouldn't even be possible without the U.S. Supreme Court's recent decision in McDonald v. Chicago, a result that Senator Feingold had urged, in a writing submitted to and considered affirmatively by that very Court.

Feingold has a record on those questions and of course he's going to — and should — reflect it off of Johnson's ill-conceived meanderings.

"I believe it's an essential American freedom," says Ron Johnson, suddenly. "Fundamental right" is the constitutional term of art impressed upon the Court by Feingold and which the Court accepted.

Senator Feingold and his fellow amici argued that the right to keep and bear arms predates the drafting of the Second Amendment itself, which should tickle even the devoutest natural law aficionados.

"The people of Wisconsin can trust me not to play politics with their Constitutional Rights while protecting our right to keep and bear arms," Johnson announces, now. But Wisconsinites were unable even to assert capital-C Constitutional rights until McDonald v. Chicago.

The irony is strong with this one and Russ Feingold needs to make much more of it. If only for Ron Johnson's edification, as the latter's provided every indication that it went sailing right over his head.

Bill Lueders's "morons" are free to make of that what they will, but the majority non-morons should give it some serious consideration.

The Constitution is worth it. Ask any of the real Tea folks.

December 29, 2009

Wisconsin's award-winning justice

Albeit not a particularly coveted award:
Lying Hypocrite of the Year: Michael Gableman
The most recent inductee into Wisconsin's once-honorable Supreme Court isn't a great legal mind or even especially qualified. But he got elected in 2008 with big-time help from big business and a campaign ad falsely suggesting his opponent found a loophole to let a child molester re-offend. Faced with a Judicial Commission complaint, he argued that the deliberately misleading ad couldn't be punished because its component parts were true. In other words, noted one judge who recommended tossing the charges, he found a loophole! Here's a 100% true statement: Justice Gableman is a disgrace.
Bill Lueders, making me feel chaste and demure by comparison.
Jim Bopp [Gableman's defense lawyer*]: It is a loophole, that had nothing to do with [Mitchell's] guilt or innocence.

Judge Snyder: "Loophole" has kind of an emotional ring to it. It wasn't so much a loophole as it just was a properly argued application of the rape shield law, was it not?

Bopp: Well, uh, it turned out to be, yes.
That little exchange is always good for a mordant chuckle. Atty. Bopp is no dummy; he knows what total bullshit it is he's defending.

* Who hails not from Wisconsin but from Terre Haute (which — irony of all ironies — translates roughly as "higher ground"), Indiana.

It's a dirty job, but somebody's got to do it. And it's funny, because Reuben Lee Mitchell had a constitutional right to Louis Butler's representation, whereas Gableman has none to Jim Bopp's, his current and ongoing predicament being a civil controversy (although there's nothing at all civil about the cheap sleaze at the heart of it).

December 10, 2009

Butler, J., dissents (opinion filed)

Bill Lueders — Justice for Forest Shomberg

Remember him? Because I do.
The defense in this matter was that someone other than the defendant committed these offenses, and that Shomberg was mistakenly identified as the perpetrator. Relying on established scientific research, the expert testimony that he sought to introduce would have addressed factors that have a significant bearing on a witness's ability to identify a stranger, as well as explained how these factors impact the accuracy of a witness's recollection. Notwithstanding the cross-examination of the eyewitnesses and jury instructions, expert testimony would still have assisted the trier of fact. This testimony would certainly have had a tendency to make the existence of each witness's identification of Shomberg as the perpetrator less probable than it would have been without it, and therefore relevant to his innocence.
State v. Forest Shomberg, 2006 WI 9, 72 (Butler, J., dissenting).

"The people of Wisconsin deserve better." — F. James Sensenbrenner

Ol' F. James is not right about much, now is he.

March 27, 2009

Koschnick's chickens come home to roost

A certain measure of Karma finally caught up this week with Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick, whose dissonant political posturing is fast approaching its nadir of absurdity. Judge Koschnick is said to be in pursuit of a seat on the Wisconsin Supreme Court on election day, April 7.

And yesterday he may have surrendered whatever political credibility he had remaining, squandering the brief surge he enjoyed while he frolicked with Joe the Plumber and amusingly copped to digesting that grande dame of Republican letters Ann Coulter's Godless.

After several months spent deploying a partisan fusillade comprised of acting the hypocrite, misstating the law, making baseless accusations, insulting his colleagues, and flat-out lying, Koschnick was apparently startled to learn that somebody had gotten wise to his charades and used them to take a bite out of his own dorsal facade.

Let's call it rational basis with teeth.

Promises, Promises

Playing off of Judge Koschnick's very own relentless campaign message, a third-party issue outfit reasonably inferred from his stump performances some not-so-veiled promises to rule against the types of parties who prevailed in the cases Koschnick has been making a grandiose issue out of since November.

The Greater Wisconsin Committee began running television ads this past Tuesday that accuse Koschnick of favoring corporate interests as against the victims of, e.g., products manufacturing negligence and medical malpractice.

To be sure, it's not as if the GWC picked up on some singular, offhand remark of Koschnick's.

Rather, it relied on the circuit judge's central political thesis, pummeling away as he has for months at every available opportunity on the same handful of Wisconsin Supreme Court decisions carefully chosen from a decades-deep archive of several thousand.

Evidently Judge Koschnick was both shocked and appalled that somebody just might conceivably take him at his word.

Shameless petulance

He reacted yesterday by firing off two letters, one to what the First Amendment refers to as the free press, urging it to prostrate itself before his capricious desires and stop airing the ads, and the other to Chief Justice Abrahamson, imploring her to join his petty crusade.

Abrahamson's campaign responded appropriately, advising Judge Koschnick that if he has a problem with the broadcasts, then it's likewise up to him to do something about it. That's his business.

Koschnick's reaction would have been merely laughable, had it not been accompanied by deliberately malicious petulance. Koschnick's campaign "adviser," a wannabe Republican fixer called Seamus Flaherty, attempted to pin the blame on the Chief Justice.

Flaherty shamelessly attributed ownership of the ad to Abrahamson herself and lied about the Chief Justice's response to a question posed by Bill Lueders in a Madison paper, the Isthmus — she hadn't declined to answer it, she declined to "speculate about the future."

That's a big difference, and furthermore, when a journalist doesn't receive a yes or no answer to a loaded question, he's in no wise entitled to portray whatever answer he does get as a refusal to reply.

Nice 'N' Sleazy

Flaherty claimed the Chief Justice was actively relying on "sleaze merchants" to do her "dirty work" but without offering the slightest whiff of evidence connecting Abrahamson to the GWC.

It's abundantly clear who is the sleaze merchant in this affair and all of Mr. Seamus Flaherty's published and spoken campaign pronouncements bear the official imprimatur of Koschnick himself.

Moreover, Koschnick's correspondence to the Chief Justice itself contains a false statement of fact, whereby Koschnick accuses the GWC of making an "admission" it never made and furthermore, attributing this non-existent "admission" to an Associated Press report that contained no such "admission," all of which earned the judge a polite cease and desist letter from the GWC's counsel.

Additional handwringing over the third-party outfit's entry into the campaign fray can likely be expected, but it seems to this observer that the teevee spot's inference is broadly defensible.

And unfortunately for Jefferson County Judge Randy Koschnick, it's his own endless loop of well documented partisan rhetoric and hyperbole that provides the most effective grounds for its defense.

March 23, 2009

Your Monday pundit round-up

Local medium wave radio shouter Charlie Sykes, who also operates a teevee show called "Sunday Insight" [sic] did a segment yesterday on the current State Supreme Court election.

Predictably, there was little insight to be gained, or at least not anything in the way of actual edification.

The hapless Sykes had roughly squat to contribute, aside from insisting on referring to former Justice Louis Butler as "Louie," as if he's his best buddy or something (in fact, Louis rhymes with Lewis).

Nor did another "distinguished panelist," the Journal-Sentinel's guide to good reading on the Web, Patrick McIlheran, who may or may not be feeling a modicum of shame over the unapologetically despicable treatment he afforded the Supreme Court election last year.

Yet another participant, the famed Walnuts-Begger of Waukesha, James T. "Hip Musings" Harris, dismissed Community Journal editor Mikel Holt's suggestion that the 2008 Michael Gableman campaign had appealed to racial prejudices among the electorate because — get a load of this — nobody knew Louis Butler was black.

Never mind that Holt was referring to Michael Gableman's notorious broadcast ad which included several shots of Butler, including those presented side by each with a black convicted child molester.

As a fellow cartoon character effectively put it, that Harris, whose continuing appearances on a programme alleged to provide "Insight" can only be attributed to inadvertent comic relief, he's about as sharp as a sack of ballpeen hammers.

Harris went on to say the real issue in the ongoing campaign should be "the lead paint case." Forgive me if I doubt whether Harris has even read it. Rather, somebody probably told him that the Wall Street Journal once ran an editorial saying mean things about Wisconsin and this troubled him and inspired a typically hip musing.

Finally, "pundit" Kenneth Lamke made reference to a lengthy piece that appeared in Madison's alternative weekly, the Isthmus, which Lamke described as "laudatory" of candidate Randy Koschnick.

Given Madison's perceived political culture, an alternative weekly in that town is deemed chortlingly by the Sykesians to be reflective of views slightly to the left of the International Workers' Daily, hence Lamke apparently finding Lueders's piece especially remarkable.

Except there are a number of disturbing misconceptions in Lueders's article, and consequently with Lamke's portrayal of it.

First of all, it contains a grotesque mangling of the central holdings of a State Supreme Court decision — which remains embarrassingly uncorrected nearly two weeks after its publication online.

Second, Mr. Lueders is not so much "lauding" Randy Koschnick as he is comparing him with Michael Gableman, who Lueders called, among other things, "a man without honor or shame." So Lueders would presumably prefer just about any candidate with a pulse — who knows, maybe even James T. Harris — to Gableman, which isn't exactly a "laudatory" endorsement of Randy Koschnick.

But the biggest problems with Lueders's piece reside with his subjective and untenable expectations of Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson. First, he's disappointed with what he personally believes are unsatisfactory replies to his questions, even though they are each perfectly appropriate and more than sufficiently responsive.

Then there is this, wherein Lueders grouses that the Chief Justice isn't political enough for his tastes:
Abrahamson, for her part, fervently rejects the suggestion that she approaches cases with any ideological predispositions: "I do what the facts and law require."

It's a good argument to make, but unconvincing.
Oh? Then if Lueders is unconvinced, he needs initially to prove up those so-called "ideological predispositions." But he doesn't even try, apart from pointing to "some" other people's reactions:
While a surprisingly large share of Supreme Court cases are decided unanimously, some do break down along obviously ideological lines. At least some of Abrahamson's supporters believe she'll apply the law in ways that favor injured people over corporations and the rights of the criminal defendants, some innocent, over the power of the state. That's why they support her.
What Lueders refers to as "ideology" is no such thing, but rather differing approaches to interpreting statutes, constitutions, case law, legal history, contemporary meanings of language, etc., etc.

It's easy to toss around quasi-philosophical characterizations, but without some detailed explanation, context, and support, they're effectively substanceless buzzwords.

This, however, is the real capper:
Abrahamson's reluctance to affirm and defend these leanings undercut her appeal. She's running from her own record of progressivism, which she should be trumpeting.
Talk about assuming your own defective conclusions.

And, well, too bad, because that ain't the way it works. And Abrahamson has continually been affirming and defending her approach to judging cases, for anyone who's been paying attention.

Furthermore there is the record itself. In each of Abrahamson's written opinions — in particular the so-called "controversial" ones that Judge Koschnick has been judiciously cherry-picking his way through — her approach is carefully and exhaustively explained.

But none of these "pundits" ever wants to talk about that; they prefer obsessing over the results, avoiding any meaningful debate about whether the reasoning and approach to that result was sound.

(And of course nobody has been obsessing over results with greater alacrity than Koschnick himself, which is unusual because as a self-described "judicial conservative," obsession with results is supposed to be the exclusive province of "liberal activists." To be sure, that's one of the signature political rationales behind portraying oneself as a "judicial conservative" in the first place: to attack "results-oriented" liberal judges. The irony is jarring.)

So what more does Mr. Lueders expect of Chief Justice Abrahamson? Because those detailed explications of her reasoning in each case are exactly what he's looking for, yet complains he doesn't find.

Moreover, why should any judge have an obligation to "defend" the perceptions of "some" other people? And why in the world would a judge be "trumpeting" any political ideology to begin with? That would be fundamentally inappropriate to the very function of judging.

Lueders may have interviewed Chief Justice Abrahamson for his article, but it's a shame he wasn't more thoughtfully considering her responses. On the other hand, Lueders appears pleased by Judge Koschnick's outright political pandering to conservative Republicans.

Perhaps that's how judges go about getting themselves elected in the State of Wisconsin, and some people might even find it attractive. But it certainly has nothing to do with the jobs they're seeking after.

March 12, 2009

No Pulitzer Prize for Madison paper

Bill Lueders in the Isthmus cites to a particular opinion of the Wisconsin Supreme Court as "perhaps the best example" of Judge Randy Koschnick's crusade against "judicial activism," claiming:
Four of the seven justices decided that, henceforth, juvenile confessions would be inadmissible as evidence unless they were videotaped. Koschnick is appalled by this.
I suppose he might well be appalled, except that that is hardly what the Jerrell majority determined. What it decided was this:
[W]e exercise our supervisory power to require that all custodial interrogation of juveniles in future cases be electronically recorded where feasible, and without exception when questioning occurs at a place of detention.
Indeed, Justice Ann Walsh Bradley's lead opinion publishes this statement no fewer than three times. It takes real effort to overlook. Followed by an extensive explication of the court's supervisory power over evidentiary matters in State courts and its justification in the instant case, authored by Chief Justice Abrahamson.

Therefore, what Mr. Lueders needed to ask Judge Koschnick is this: Was the majority's reasoning flawed, or is he simply troubled by its outcome. That is the pertinent line of inquiry regarding any appellate decision: The process employed, not simply the result obtained.

In any event, the purpose of this decision is to protect both juvenile suspects and law enforcement. Also — obviously — the overarching concern here is for the preservation of our ideal of justice.

Notwithstanding the general availability of AAA batteries.

So: Not videotaping. Audiotaping. And even then, only where such recording is feasible. And not during all interrogations, only custodial interrogations. That is, after the juvenile suspect has been taken into custody, as custody itself has been defined in the case law.

And the only venue where audio recordings (not videotaping) are required without exception is at places of detention, e.g., in jail.

Goodness, I'd sure hate to see the worst example.

It's not that hard to read these cases. Even a journalist can do it.

November 28, 2008

Yeah, this is the Big Bopper speakin'

David Ziemer is a bit more upset with the Capital Times than I was.

Ziemer, who contributes exemplary reportage and analysis to the Wisconsin Law Journal, thinks it was pretty irresponsible of the Cap Times to suggest that Mike Gableman shares the personal views of his attorney.

To be sure, Ziemer is correct and the more firmly grounded assumption is that Gableman retained Indiana lawyer James Bopp, Jr. on account of the latter's enhanced competence and expertise in that field where election law and freedom of speech intersect.

But that doesn't mean his selection is insignificant. Because Bopp probably wanted the case as much as Gableman wanted him on it. Bopp is into challenging these restrictions all over the country.

Bopp is also lead counsel in another action currently pending before a federal court in Wisconsin, Siefert v. Alexander.

John Siefert is a Milwaukee County Circuit Court Judge who is likewise challenging the constitutionality of several provisions of the State's Supreme Court Rules, the ones pertaining to partisan political activities and direct fundraising by judicial candidates.

The adverse party, James Alexander, is the executive director of the Wisconsin Judicial Commission, which administers the SCRs.

Judge Siefert will be up for reelection in 2011, and he wants to participate in those activities which the Rules currently forbid. He (and Bopp) argues that judges can maintain those associations while not compromising their ability to remain fair and impartial in deciding cases. It's a not unreasonable suggestion.

But the provision Gableman is attacking, SCR 60.06(3)(c), is different from the ones Judge Siefert is going after. It has to do with defaming one's electoral rivals, which is probably something self-respecting candidates for the State's highest court shouldn't be engaging in and maybe even face sanctions when they do.

Defamation is generally not found among the absolutely protected categories of speech (such as virtual child pornography, American flag burning, and conservative talk radio).

Indeed, Gableman/Bopp expressly acknowledge that aspect of the Rule's intent, except they claim that its language isn't crafted narrowly enough to achieve that goal and that the Rule serves to capture and proscribe non-defamatory statements as well.

Maybe so, but that's why there's a judicial commission to evaluate and assess individual complaints arising under the Rules.

This is one among Gableman/Bopp's numerous objections, of course, including their defense that the "allegedly" misleading advertisement was simply an innocent and informative collection of disconnected, objectively true statements in no sense meant to suggest or imply anything further about Gableman's political opponent.

Yeah, right. As if the ad wasn't making a broader statement, the sum of its parts so to speak, supported additionally by the insidious visual and aural elements. It was also frankly demeaning and insulting to its intended audience and others, but that's a separate question and there's no Rule against overtly cynical, grasping political ambition.

Rather, it occasionally merits both encouragement and reward.

As Isthmus news editor Bill Lueders puts it,
Gableman wants the rule struck down, so future judicial candidates can more freely lie their way into office. What a fitting legacy that would be for Justice Gableman.
That's not an entirely unfair assessment, if you ask me.

Yet Justice Gableman's detractors had better start to brace themselves. If I were a betting man, I'd wager SCR 60.06(3)(c) will not survive First Amendment scrutiny, if this case happens to get that far. Nor would I consider it much cause for celebration.

But for Bopp/Gableman, it would be victory and vindication. Which is, to co-opt from the thrust of Gableman's legal attack against the Rule, also both prima facie wrong and especially wrong as applied.