Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Steven Walters. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query Steven Walters. Sort by date Show all posts

July 10, 2009

Reporter still carrying water for Koschnick

The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel's Steven Walters, reporting on this morning's Wisconsin Supreme Court decision in Phelps v. Physicians Insurance Co. of Wisconsin, Inc., reminds us that the law firm representing the plaintiffs contributed to the reelection campaign of Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson:
Abrahamson's opponent, Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick, said Abrahamson had taken campaign contributions from Phelps' family lawyers in the case.

Koschnick said that Abrahamson, to avoid any appearance of having a conflict of interest, should have either not participated in the case or returned the donations from those lawyers.

Abrahamson joined [Justice Ann] Walsh Bradley's dissent.
One may fairly speculate as to what Mr. Walters is implying here, by placing that final sentence on the heels of the preceding two.

Because it has more to do with reporting the result of the case than with whatever accusations Koschnick was leveling against the Chief Justice last spring (and there were many, a good number of them being either baseless or else "grossly inaccurate and misleading").

Yet Steven Walters's dispatch contains nary a hint of the political campaign contributions made to several members of the Phelps majority by attorneys working for the adversary law firm, Foley & Lardner, which represented the insurance company defendants.

Why might that be, I wonder.

April 6, 2009

Koschnick completes rejection of coherence

The people have the right to keep and bear arms for security, defense, hunting, recreation or any other lawful purpose.
Wis. Const. art. I, § 25

Any person except a peace officer who goes armed with a concealed and dangerous weapon is guilty of a Class A misdemeanor.
Wis. Stat. § 941.23
For his third article in as many days helpfully stumping for Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel's Steven Walters adds yet another contradiction to Koschnick's so-called "judicial philosophy." A very large one.

Here we find Koschnick grousing about Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson's dissenting opinion in State v. Hamdan, a 2003 decision of the State Supreme Court in which Abrahamson did exactly what Koschnick is more typically complaining about her not doing: applying the law "as written" and refusing to "legislate from the bench."

Hamdan-handed

Hamdan addressed the extent to which the constitutional provision reproduced above in its entirety implicated Wisconsin's carrying a concealed weapon statute, also reproduced above in its entirety.

But in Hamdan, a majority of the court effectively rewrote the CCW statute, creating by judicial fiat two exceptions for persons in their "private residence[s] or privately operated business[es]."

For months Koschnick has been going about calling himself a "strict constructionist" and promising not to "legislate from the bench."

In Hamdan, not only did the majority refrain from strictly construing the CCW law under the particular facts presented, it "legislated from the bench" by creating exceptions to the statute so as to prevent it from being applied against the defendant, Munir Hamdan.

And despite the Journal-Sentinel's wildly misleading headline — "Candidates clash over gun ownership" — Abrahamson's dissent has nothing whatsoever to do with gun ownership. It barely has anything to do with guns at all, let alone evincing "a hostility to gun owners," the latest in a continuing series of Koschnick's ridiculous charges.

Rather, the Chief Justice's Hamdan dissent is a more or less academic exercise in statutory construction, the question of how and when a statute violates the constitution, and the proper role of the courts with respect to their relationship to the legislature.

That it happens to involve a handgun is purely a matter of convenience to Judge Koschnick's partisan political agenda, and he's apparently willing to abandon his commitment to his own "judicial philosophy" in order to exploit it.

Moreover, it's Chief Justice Abrahamson's dissenting opinion that embodies the twin hallmarks of Koschnick's own oft-articulated "judicial philosophy": reading the law "as written" and a refusal to "legislate from the bench."

In his pants

The majority agreed that Hamdan, by carrying a concealed handgun wrapped up in his pants pocket, broke the law:
During the time that Hamdan came from the back room and engaged in conversation with the police officers, he was going armed with a concealed and dangerous weapon. Because the jury concluded that Hamdan was aware of the weapon's presence and that the weapon was hidden or concealed from ordinary view, we conclude that Hamdan violated the CCW statute.
The majority also determined that the CCW statute itself "on its face" does not violate the Wisconsin constitution.

But, reacting to the particular circumstances of Hamdan's case, the majority created two more exceptions to the statute and then proceeded to apply them to those circumstances in order to reach its determination that the application of the CCW statute was unconstitutional in Hamdan's particular situation.

In doing so, the court substituted its judgment — which included a considerable amount of not only speculation but internally contradictory speculation — for that of the legislative branch.

As Abrahamson pointed out, if the court believed that those exceptions were lacking from the CCW statute, then it must find the law unconstitutional and return those questions to the legislature, whose business it is to create such exceptions, a regular feature of legislative provisions (note, e.g., the "peace officer" exception).

This is not "activism." Quite the opposite. This is mindfulness of the constitutional separation of powers and deference to the accepted roles of those separate branches of government, which is precisely what one hears Koschnick rambling on about constantly.

The court shouldn't create additional exceptions in statutes — nor has it the power to — in order to save them from constitutional infirmity. But that is exactly what the majority did in State v. Hamdan.

In short, if Judge Koschnick really did have a coherent and consistent "judicial philosophy," then he would be praising and not criticizing Chief Justice Abrahamson's State v. Hamdan dissent.

And assuming there really is such a thing as "legislating from the bench" — "legislating" being a term of art which describes a process not possible to perform "from the bench" — then the majority's reasoning in Hamdan counts among its definitive exemplars.

A theory twice rejected

Meanwhile, and perhaps most tellingly of all, Koschnick is quoted* in the Journal-Sentinel as saying that "what happened here" (in Hamdan) involved "gun rights - including self-defense," even though "defense" is a separate purpose in the constitution that was never successfully argued in Hamdan.

In fact the court explicitly rejected Hamdan's argument that he had a statutory privilege of self-defense (see ¶¶ 29-37). More to the point, it also explicitly rejected Hamdan's appeal to the defense element of the constitutional provision:
Although Hamdan's conduct could arguably be construed as undertaken for the purpose of "defense," we think the circumstances logically point to the purpose of "security."
That is, "security" and "defense" are two separate purposes in the constitutional provision, just as are "defense" and "hunting" separate purposes. So much for "strict constructionism." Again.

But Steven Walters, apparently without detecting a hint of irony, reports: "Yet, Koschnick said, Abrahamson 'missed that.'"

All of which leads one to inquire — again — as to whether Koschnick has even read this decision. And if so, why the misrepresentation.

Because this is the same Judge Randy Koschnick who admonished the Chief Justice — of all people — that the task of describing the decisions of the courts "requires precision." That it certainly does.

So, I can't help wondering: What in the world is a self-proclaimed "more qualified" candidate for the Supreme Court doing describing an opinion of that court as the validation of an argument which a majority of that very same court expressly rejected?

And rejected not just once but two times!

For Judge Koschnick to point at Chief Justice Abrahamson's dissent in State v. Hamdan as providing support for his own continuously advertised status as a "strict constructionist" and his own promise not to "legislate from the bench" is, in a word, ludicrous.

It's no surprise, then, that less than 20% of Wisconsin's registered electors turn out to vote in Supreme Court elections. The rest of them are probably weary of having their intelligence insulted.

* "When they amended the state constitution in November 1998, Wisconsin voters made it clear they want 'pretty broad gun rights - including self-defense,' Koschnick said. 'That's what happened here.'"

February 3, 2011

Kloppenburg not partisan, activist, nor advocate

JoAnne Kloppenburg, the assistant attorney general who's running for the Wisconsin Supreme Court, distinguishes herself from her opponents in an interview Monday with Steven Walters:
Kloppenburg: What is a campaign issue is what [incumbent Justice David Prosser] has said in his campaign. He said that he is the conservative candidate and will be the conservative justice. His campaign said that he will complement the work of the new governor and the legislature and that of the four candidates he is best able to work with the legislature.

The court is a separate and co-equal branch of government and at times it is a check on the legislature at the same time that it might, it reviews legislation and it may support the legislature or it may not, but you don't know ahead of time. For him to telegraph how he's inclined to rule is a real problem and is a real issue in this campaign.

In addition to Justice Prosser, we have Joel Winnig who talked about how he will work to change laws.

Walters: Yes, he has a very activist view of justice.*

Kloppenburg: An activist is someone who prejudges cases, like Justice Prosser, or who says he's going to change laws, like Joel Winnig. If you want to do that, you run for the legislature, you don't run for the court. And then Marla Stephens has said she'll be an advocate for the court. I've litigated cases around the State; in fact ... as a litigator, I'm the one who advocates. The judge needs to be impartial and independent.
Kloppenburg also said of Michael Gableman's notorious 2008 child molester teevee ad, "any reasonable person would call that ad to be a lie," and the perception created by the Supreme Court's 3-3 split in the subsequent ethics case against Gableman was that it was drawn along partisan lines and that it had damaged the court's reputation.

Nevertheless Kloppenburg agreed with three of those justices, in that the case against Gableman should have moved forward rather than letting it hang out there pending without any resolution:**
I have not read the full record, and I think that the justices who would have moved the case forward would have called for a trial in order that more facts could be brought out.
In fact it's not at all clear from the State statutes that the Wisconsin Judicial Commission, which brought the complaint against Gableman, retained a legal option to present its case to a jury. For that reason the Commission announced it would suspend prosecuting its complaint in the wake of the 3-3 split, but has never joined any motion requesting that the complaint be formally dismissed.

The primary election takes place February 15, which will most likely reduce the slate of candidates to Justice Prosser and one of the three current challengers. JoAnne Kloppenburg leads the fundraising race.

Link to the full interview is here (30 min.).

* I like how reporter Walters jumps in there to fire this shot.

** The court had convened on Gableman's motion for summary judgment (dismissal) which Gableman failed to win. There it sits.

December 17, 2009

Court catching political hell, says former justice

Local blogger lobbies for paralegals to decide appellate cases

Good, comprehensive piece in the Madison Capital Times this morning. The Wisconsin Supreme Court's December 7 public conference truly is a wonder to behold, and what Steven Elbow describes as "rancor among the justices" is accurate.

Understatement, really.
"I don't want to study this so that people out there can kind of lob hand grenades over and over and over at certain members of the court," Justice Prosser said.
Well, I think we know who they might be:
Conservatives on the court are enjoying their 4-3 majority thanks in part to Wisconsin Manufacturers & Commerce, which spent about $4 million on television ads to get Justice Annette Ziegler and Gableman elected in 2007 and 2008, respectively. The big-business lobbying group wrote one of the rules that the court adopted on a 4-3 vote.
More intriguing was Prosser's dig at Justice Crooks (by extension a dig at Chief Justice Abrahamson and Justice Bradley as well):
"It seems to me, Justice Crooks, that four members of the court can do that. You've been a member of the four people on the court who have rammed things through before, and you just don't happen to be part of the four now." He went on to tell Crooks that "it's ridiculous for you to make this argument."
Yet it's three of those "four now" (Prosser, Roggensack, and our old buddy Mike Gableman) who are responsible for the rancor and sarcasm on display at the public conference. It ain't exactly a gracious majority (Justice Ziegler doesn't say too much).

Justice Crooks's argument isn't particularly ridiculous, but it depends on how substantial are the changes to the proposed ethics rules, which is something Justice Prosser refused to elaborate on throughout the two-hour conference despite repeated requests.

It's fair to say they're well beyond being scrivener's errors.

Justice Prosser needs to win an election on April 5, 2011,* if he wants to remain a member of that gracious majority. Sources say Democrats are casting about for an appropriately 110% pro-criminal candidate to challenge him (I'll consider it; Judy Faulkner: call me).

Meanwhile, public cynicism regarding the court is off the charts:
Early last year, a poll of 600 likely Wisconsin voters commissioned by Justice at Stake, a national nonpartisan watchdog group, found that only 5 percent of respondents believe that campaign contributions have no influence on judges' decisions.
Six hundred is a small sample, but still: 95 percent think the State Supreme Court makes decisions based on who and what contributed to their political campaigns. Lovely.

Yet most folks still believe it's a great idea to elect them? That tells you that Wisconsinites are content having a court that places a higher value on cash money than legal principle. This can't be, can it?

As in, "The West Virginia of the North" (now there's a Wall Street Journal editorial you'll never see).

The poll result might reach 100 percent if people thought about why the four conservatives were so eager to adopt the language of proposals that turns out to be so internally contradictory that one of them actually had to rescind his vote in favor of adopting them.

And it wasn't even those justices who noticed: it had to be pointed out to them in a November letter from the two well-connected business consortiums that submitted the proposals in the first place.

Former justice William Bablitch, incidentally, made probably the most impassioned and impressive presentation on the deleterious effects of money-influence to the court in October.

Some may recall the statements Bablitch delivered to former Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reporter Steven Walters about Chief Justice Abrahamson that were enthusiastically seized upon by Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick during the latter's unsuccessful bid to unseat the CJ earlier this year.

Koschnick was profoundly troubled** that Abrahamson had voted to declare unconstitutional Wisconsin's Chapter 980, which enables the State to commit convicted sex offenders to continued confinement even beyond the length of their original sentences.

Bablitch criticized Abrahamson for that vote ("well out of the mainstream," whatever that means — in 1997, a similar question arising out of Kansas was decided 5-4 by the U.S. Supreme Court***) and Koschnick placed Bablitch's criticism at the top of his campaign website, but neither of them (nor Mr. Walters the reporter, for that matter) bothered to inform anybody that then-Justice Bablitch had also voted to find Chapter 980 unconstitutional.

Pretty slick. But hey, they are lawyers, after all. Perhaps the most effective solution would be to ban them from sitting on the bench.

eta:
I am a former employee of the Wisconsin Supreme Court. I worked for the Court as a law clerk for one of the justices. I USED to be proud of that fact and was never hesitant to mention it at appropriate times. Not true now. I find it appalling that the current Court is bought and paid for by lobby groups and they even have no hesitancy in acknowledging it. For years the Wisconsin Supreme Court enjoyed the highest reputation for its integrity and the quality of its decisions. Now, it is rarely cited by other jurisdictions and is generally considered to be a second rate court. The most recent Justices to be elected are not of sufficient quality to do anything other than write or vote for the legal positions supported by those organizations that paid to put them in office. The only salvation for the Wisconsin Supreme Court is for the U.S. Supreme Court to limit the corruption of the four Justices who currently enjoy a majority on the court.
— "Cynical," an aptly-monikered CapTimes commenter.

* The last two Supreme Court elections were each attended by around 20% of registered Wisconsin voters.

** He was also "troubled" that Abrahamson couldn't meet him for a candidate's debate because she was busy hearing oral arguments.

*** That Court will be entertaining arguments on federal civil commitments for sex offenders next month, but the questions presented there are much different.

June 22, 2010

Johnson misrepresents Feingold Senate vote

Being the first of many misrespresentations to come, undoubtedly.

Not so long ago, Republican candidate for U.S. Senate Dave Westlake served as last-minute understudy for missing GOP rival Ron Johnson at a Madison, Wisconsin Tea Party affair.

Johnson disappeared after his notoriously "disastrous" performance last week, a YouTubed excursion to a deep woods Patriot clubhouse where Johnson dismayed Tea Party sympathizers not only with his inability to address specific Tea concerns, but with his failure to even recognize their most cherished constitutional ideals.

Some were led to wonder: Was he Tea or wasn't he GOP?

Yesterday morning Johnson emerged in the affluent Milwaukee suburb of Brookfield presumably after days of relentless murder-boarding with his new internets research specialist to face Westlake and WisPolitics.com's intrepid presenter Steven Walters.*

U.S. legal system derived from Bible stories

Seizing another opportunity, Westlake went on Full Tea Mode in Brookfield, calling for the abolition of the federal Departments of Education and Energy along with the IRS. He announced that in every Biblical story, one "undeniably" finds a little bit of Constitution, some Declaration of Independence, and a treatise on patent and trademark prosecution, and that the Second Amendment "defines who we are."

He proclaimed the Federal Reserve "a consumer threat," denounced Obama for performing "nothing more than a shakedown" on British Petroleum yachtsman-in-chief Tony Hayward, whose industry's safety record Westlake deemed "impeccable," and demanded that obese, sedentary tobacco smokers accept responsibility for their own poor health and stop insisting everybody else pay to take care of them.

Westlake also spoke emotionally of values and morality and especially moral hazards (to wit, federal unemployment benefits extended for another week or two, and their resultant Devilish temptation of the beneficiary to remain unemployed in perpetuity, in accordance with Tea Party psychology and prophesy).

Mr. Ron Johnson was less than truthful

Candidate Johnson came armed with new quips researched and served up from the deep recesses of the Googles, including one about how Senator Russ Feingold "voted for funding a sanctuary cities [sic]." Which sounds a lot like, "Feingold voted directly in support of something having to do with funding whatever thing it is that makes a sanctuary city a sanctuary city," doesn't it?

Except Johnson's implication is just a bit wide of the mark. Last October, Feingold voted to table (kill) a one-liner nuisance amendment advanced by wingnut Republican Sens. David Vitter and James Inhofe to withhold funding from COPS, a program in place and duly appropriated for since 1994. COPS is devoted to assisting selected local law enforcement engaged in specialized challenges.

For example, combating the social blight and attendant crime of methamphetamine addiction in distressed communities where State or municipal resources are otherwise unavailable.

There wasn't any connection between any particular city's so-called sanctuary ordinance — which discourages municipal employees from participating in immigration investigations except where required by the law — and COPS. Save that connection fabricated inside the roiling medullae oblongatae of Messrs. Vitter and Inhofe.

In fact a number of Republicans joined Sen. Feingold in opposing Vitter and Inhofe's transparent, regressive grandstanding.

Johnson said of immigration, which he claimed "is one of the weakest issues [Feingold's] on," that Feingold "has a zero rating from a group that basically calls for open borders." But wouldn't that be a good thing? Perhaps it will take Johnson a few more days to properly digest all of that newly discovered internets research.

Elena Kagan already "probably disqualified"

In a similar vein, Johnson also asserted that Feingold "voted for partial birth abortion seven times." Obviously nobody votes for "partial birth abortion." But Russ Feingold has certainly voted against placing onerous federal restrictions on women's access to what is and has been for decades — whether Ron Johnson likes it or not — a legal and constitutionally protected right: "the settled law of the land."

Johnson's embedded accusation that supporters of abortion's safe and legal availability are by definition active proponents of infanticide may be the most disingenuous of conservative Republican fallacies.

Among other freshly released Johnson zingers, the candidate determined that Supreme Court nominee Elena Kagan** was "probably disqualified" for "actually den[ying] access to military recruiters at Harvard" (another falsehood) and that the very thought of Obama having the authority to appoint federal judges was "depressing."

And he repeated his nonsense about knee replacements in Canada, adding a new twist: that it's not unusual to wait one year to receive a coronary bypass in Germany, which sounds equally preposterous.

WisconsinEye supplies the video.

* Sample Walters inquiry: "Do you support President Obama's move to require BP to set up a $20 million [sic] trust fund for oil spill damage that came ahead of any formal finding of criminal or civil negligence?" Both candidates answered "No" based almost entirely on the response Walters had thoughtfully provided in the question.

** Said Dave Westlake of Elena Kagan: "I don't have a whole lot of confidence in nominee Kagan. She's never served in any capacity similar to what she'd be experiencing on the federal court." But neither has Westlake served in any capacity similar to what he'd be experiencing in the federal legislature. As such, not among the most compelling or tactical objections to Elena Kagan's qualifications.

March 3, 2009

Can Koschnick get any less coherent?

Over the weekend, the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel ran a laughably superficial and disingenuous "report" on the Wisconsin Supreme Court election. Front section-page, in the hard copies. Above the fold.

In the piece, reporter Steven Walters helpfully repeated a pile of Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick's unsubstantiated charges* against Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson.

In accord with that paper's standard practice, not a single syllable was expended in an attempt to investigate the veracity of Koschnick's allegations. Easier just to uncritically reprise them, evidently, whether they can withstand scrutiny or not.

As Bill Christofferson says, Koschnick might as well just fire his campaign staff and leave it all to Walters and the Journal-Sentinel.

What caught my attention particularly, however, was this quote from former Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice William Bablitch:
"I don't like the term soft on crime," Bablitch said. "But (Abrahamson) seems to be well out of the mainstream when it comes to criminal matters involving the criminal rights of defendants."
Predictably, Koschnick seized on this utterance with both hands and published it at the top of his campaign website's index page.

But elsewhere, Koschnick alleges that Abrahamson has been "60% pro-criminal" during a selected period of time on the court. He purports to have arrived at this figure by looking at the court's written opinions since 2000, in particular those cases whose docket number contains the suffix "-CR," which denotes a criminal appeal.

Justice Bablitch retired from the court on July 31, 2003, so he shared some concurrent time on the bench with the Chief Justice.

And it wasn't just concurrent time.

As a matter of fact, during the period Judge Koschnick cites to, Shirley Abrahamson had no more reliable ally on decisions in criminal appeals than — you guessed it — Justice William Bablitch.

Not only that, but in a number of cases where Abrahamson and Bablitch were at odds, Abrahamson ruled for the State and Bablitch authored a lone dissent finding for the defendant's interests.

And we all know how Randy Koschnick feels about lone dissents.

So it's rather curious that Bablitch is now deriding the Chief Justice for being "well out of the mainstream." Perhaps he means that the Chief hasn't "sided with criminals" enough, to borrow a phrase from the 2008 campaign of Michael Gableman, which has been replaying itself to a remarkable extent through the efforts of Judge Koschnick.

Koschnick, of course, is impervious to any of this, which isn't curious at all, since his entire campaign is erected on contradictions.

In this latest instance, he's quite happy to criticize Abrahamson's record in criminal appeals on the one hand, while with the other appropriate as an endorsement the oddball statement of a former justice whose own record is practically identical to Abrahamson's.

Koschnick might be able to put this chicanery over on Joe the Plumber, with whom he'll be sharing a stage Saturday morning, but he can't foist it on normal sentient human beings without comment.

Unfortunately, he's managing to get it past the reporters and editors at Milwaukee's only daily newspaper. And that enabling is shameful.

* Koschnick's so-called "clean campaign pledge" contains an admonition against unsubstantiated charges. At his website, Koschnick is running an animated ticker supposedly counting the days since the Chief Justice hasn't signed his "pledge."

One could be forgiven for believing the ticker is counting the days until Koschnick finally gets around to signing the thing himself.

eta: Milwaukee Magazine's Bruce Murphy thinks Bablitch is exacting revenge on the Chief because "she does not suffer fools gladly."

Nice swipe. We'll make an unmentionable blogger out of him yet.

January 31, 2009

Those bloody bloody shoes

Xoff scored this earlier, but:

Detail in Koschnick's 'bloody shirt' campaign issue emerges

So Judge Randy Koschnick himself had ruled to exclude even more damning evidence at trial: two pairs of blood-spattered shoes. His ruling was reversed by the Wisconsin Supreme Court in Knapp I.

The best part is the Koschnick campaign person's response:
Asked if Koschnick was omitting a detail of the murder case to help his campaign, Seamus Flaherty said, "We’re telling the whole story to the extent that it is relevant in this election."
I can see this guy is going to be a real barrel of laughs.

By the way, Journal-Sentinel reporter Steven Walters writes:
The issue was twice considered by the state Supreme Court, and once by the U.S. Supreme Court, because a police officer did give Knapp a Miranda warning before asking him what clothes he had been wearing. That led to the discovery of the blood sweat shirt.
No.
The issue was twice considered by the state Supreme Court, and once by the U.S. Supreme Court, because a police officer deliberately and intentionally did not give Knapp a Miranda warning before asking him what clothes he had been wearing. That led to the discovery of the bloody sweat shirt.
Fixed.

More precisely, the relevant U.S. Supreme Court decisions did not directly address the Wisconsin case insofar as it involved the deliberate and intentional withholding of the Miranda warning.

That fact is crucial to a meaningful understanding of the Wisconsin Supreme Court's disposition in Knapp II. But it's something you're also unlikely to hear from the Koschnick campaign.

I guess because it's not "relevant in this election." The hell it isn't.

When you're grandstanding about "tying the hands of law enforcement," best be aware of what law enforcement was up to.

See also: One Wisconsin Now's press release (.pdf).

October 30, 2009

It's little wonder Prosser lit into McCabe

Some observers made note of a testy exchange Wednesday between Wisconsin Supreme Court Justice David Prosser and activist Mike McCabe, at the court's public hearings on rules for judicial recusals.

Justice Prosser teed off on Mr. McCabe over several items the latter had published at his "Big Money Blog," which is part of McCabe's Wisconsin Democracy Campaign project (a useful resource, btw).

The justice was annoyed — to put it mildly — by McCabe's suggestion last June that Prosser was to sit in judgment of former State legislator Scott R. Jensen's criminal appeal, even though the record clearly shows as early as the preceding February that Prosser wasn't participating in the case.

Prosser and Jensen are estwhile colleagues in the Wisconsin State Assembly, where they served consecutively as speaker.

To make matters worse, after being notified by the Supreme Court, McCabe printed a correction the next day which, instead of leaving bad enough alone, sarcastically wondered whether Prosser was planning on appearing as a "character witness" on Jensen's behalf.

(At least, I assume it was sarcastic. Either that or McCabe believes "character witnesses" regularly appear at oral arguments before the State's highest appellate court. They do not.)

While it's true that Justice Prosser was a witness during Scott Jensen's trial at Dane County in 2006, Prosser was doing so under a subpoena — that is, an order of the court — to appear. The more serious problem with McCabe's sarcasm is that he quoted from the Wisconsin Supreme Court Rules, in particular a passage forbidding judges from "testify[ing] voluntarily as a character witness."

McCabe's implication — at least — is that Justice Prosser violated the code of judicial conduct in 2006 and was by McCabe's insinuation preparing to violate it again in 2009. One generally needs evidence for those sort of accusations, or at least supporting documentation that someone credible has made them.

But unfortunately McCabe didn't reproduce the comment below the rule (SCR 60.03(2)), which notes, "A judge may, however, testify when properly summoned." Which is to say, there is a considerable legal (and, by extension, ethical) distinction between testifying voluntarily and testifying after having been properly summoned.

And had McCabe undertaken one of those "Google is your friend" adventures, he would have easily discovered Justice Prosser telling then-Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reporter Steven Walters, "I've been subpoenaed as a witness in a criminal trial, and witnesses are expected to cooperate."

Indeed, they are. At risk of contempt.

Moreover, and while I admit I don't follow these things as closely as many others do, it's not clear to me that Prosser was specifically called as a "character witness," although he reportedly fielded a question or two concerning Scott Jensen's character.

I could be mistaken, but it appears that Justice Prosser was solicited as a witness primarily to testify generally about so-called political campaigning* by lawmakers and their aides during his tenure as a Republican leader in the State Assembly.

That's another important distinction Mr. McCabe should have taken into consideration and I would distrust (both intuitively and from vast experience) any and all press descriptions of Prosser's status as a "character witness" — which is a legal term of art as it appears in the Supreme Court Rules — without more support.

I'm all for criticizing politicians (and, sad to say, judges in Wisconsin are undeniably also politicians) but when one ventures into substantive allegations, one had best do one's homework in advance.

And, unfortunately, at least one other local blog has repeated similar allegations of wrongdoing against Justice Prosser, and it's hoped that correctives are issued in light of the foregoing.

That would serve to defuse Prosser's larger point, which was that some of those who are purportedly concerned about public perception of fairness in Wisconsin courts are themselves occasionally engaged in unwarrantedly undermining that very perception. It's a fair cop.

Anyway, to make a long story even longer, I can't say I blame Justice Prosser one bit for blowing his stack at what quite obviously and evidently justifiably appear to him to be Mr. McCabe's sloppy reporting and insinuations of impropriety. So would anybody.

* I say "so-called" because there exists a reasonable difference of opinion as to what constitutes political activity within the context of attempts to codify its definition. At one end of the continuum are those whose view is that practically everything elected officials do counts as political activity. I'm sympathetic to those observations.

Which is one of the reasons why it seems to me that electing judges is not the most compelling among other potential mechanisms.

I believe I'm in alignment with the Federalists on that account (the actual, original Federalists, that is, not the "Federalist Society").

Also — Prosser and McCabe: One more thing

November 9, 2009

Recall Gableman

Former Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel reporter Steven Walters is today hinting darkly of a whispering campaign to recall Michael Gableman from the Wisconsin Supreme Court.

A recall petition would require gathering, within 60 days, the verified signatures of 540,425 Wisconsin electors, or 115,324 more people than actually pulled the lever for Gableman in the first place.

That seems unlikely, but it would certainly be a resounding mandate.

For those who have been following the motions for recusal filed against Michael Gableman, Art. XIII, §12 ¶(1) of the Wisconsin constitution further indicates — for purposes of recall, at least — that Gableman is an incumbent elective officer who represents the State.

I kind of figured that was what Mr. James Bopp, Esq. was getting at.

March 26, 2009

Judicial conservative seeks prior restraint

Isn't this something:
Supreme Court candidate Randy Koschnick said Thursday he will ask television stations to stop airing an attack ad run by a special interest group that he called "demonstrably false."
Yet Koschnick is fine with authorizing his own campaign "adviser" to lie shamelessly about the Chief Justice. How about them apples. Apparently it's perfectly okay for Judge Koschnick to wage a purely negative political campaign, at least until the tables turn, that is.

I'm afraid Koschnick set himself up for just this sort of response in the first place, by cherry picking through selected opinions of the Supreme Court and implicitly telegraphing promises to rule otherwise when confronted with similar questions. What else did he expect?

Even worse news for Koschnick: Steven Walters is on vacation.

May 1, 2009

Steven Walters stares down a deadline

Abrahamson won't seek Souter seat

Thanks, because people were really wondering about that.

March 31, 2009

Blogger 1, Journalist 0

Bill Christofferson, a.k.a. Xoff, once again proves why he's a much better reporter than many of the ones who actually get paid to do it.

(I had a similar reaction to the Journal-Sentinel's Steven Walters's made-up non-story, incidentally. To wit: Why on earth are these poli-sci profs so baffled by Koschnick's optimistic candidate-speak?)

March 19, 2009

Koschnick flirts with rank hypocrisy

This guy is too much:
Jefferson County Judge Randy Koschnick alleged today that union endorsements of Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson reflect the incumbent justice’s tendencies toward activism during a debate in Madison today.
Yet Koschnick* was chasing after union endorsements himself.
How can anybody take him seriously, aside from this character.

And: More penetrating analysis from the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel. How come it didn't occur to J-S reporter Steven Walters to report on Judge Koschnick's blatant double standards? He covered both events, and in fact was among the three panelists at the forum last week.

Apparently he's been hypnotized by Koschnick's talking points.

* Last book read: Godless, by Ann Coulter. Quality stuff.

February 2, 2009

Bit of a disadvantage

Wisconsin Supreme Court Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson reported Monday that she raised nearly $823,000 in 2008. Her challenger Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick raised $14,700 over the same period.
Via WKBT La Crosse. But see, 35k claimed raised in January:
On Jan. 1, the Abrahamson campaign reported cash on hand of $696,100; the Koschnick campaign, $14,160.
Odd, when Steven Walters's item first appeared, that line read:
On Jan. 1, the Abrahamson campaign reported cash on hand of $696,100; the Koschnick campaign, $570.
So Randy Koschnick only spent $540 in 2008? Campaign person Seamus Flaherty must have one hella pile of invoices on his desk.

I spent $540 at T.J. Maxx.

March 15, 2009

Reporter attempts blogging

Yesterday I wondered when local journalists were going to start reporting on the many fundamentally contradictory messages of Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick, who says he's more qualified to sit on the Wisconsin Supreme Court than its veteran Chief Justice, Shirley Abrahamson.

The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel's Steven Walters tries his hand:
When asked about Abrahamson's age, the 48-year-old Koschnick said: "I don't think it's an issue. I'm not going to make it an issue."

But in campaign appearances, the Jefferson County circuit judge has repeatedly said: "I won't run for a third term (if elected). I think two terms is enough. . . . I think 32 years is too long."
Nope. Term limits do not equal age. The requirements are fairly minimal, and it's conceivable that a Wisconsin justice could have served two terms by the time they were Koschnick's age. Try again.

There are enough contradictions available without inventing one.

March 12, 2009

Koschnick the not-so-strict constructionist

For a candidate who constantly accuses his opponent of massaging the law to suit her "activist" predispositions, Jefferson County Circuit Judge Randy Koschnick is himself pretty slick at molding it to conform with his own (non-partisan) political agenda.

At a judicial debate forum in Milwaukee yesterday, both Judge Koschnick and Wisconsin Supreme Court Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson were asked to state their views on Siefert v. Alexander, a recent decision of a United States district court that invalidated as unconstitutional three provisions of the State judicial ethics rules.

Koschnick said he approved of Judge Barbara Crabb's handiwork, despite its being an example of so-called judicial activism — not to mention a federal incursion into the business of a State.

Judge Koschnick, prefatory to taking the Chief Justice to task for doing exactly what he's done himself — accepting campaign contributions from lawyers with cases that came before their respective courts — had the following to say:
And an interesting contrast that Justice [sic] Crabb laid out that I agree with. She said that there is a significant danger posed by ethics rules that allow candidates and sitting judges to take donations from lawyers who have pending cases. So if this dangerous practice is allowed in Wisconsin, it doesn't make sense to prohibit the much less threatening practices of allowing judges and justices to declare party affiliation or to personally solicit donations.
While Judge Crabb arguably implied somewhere a remotely applicable reference to a situation tangentially comparable to the very specific one Koschnick invokes, her remarks were far more general than Koschnick might like his would-be supporters to believe.

Moreover, in striking down the State ethics rule that required judicial candidates to solicit campaign funds through committees as opposed to doing so directly and personally, the federal judge said such exchanges may have a coercive effect on the contribution's donor, not necessarily its recipient, the candidate.

In other words, the "danger" contemplated in Siefert is that such potential donors might feel obligated by the need to contribute to a judicial candidate's campaign.

The opinion even provides an example of the same from Florida, where a judge's surrogate rang up an attorney with a case pending before that judge to thank the attorney for his written endorsement but reminding him the envelope was barren of cash monies.

Yet the situation Koschnick is attempting to invoke is precisely opposite of the one Judge Crabb mentions. That's what we call "standing the law on its head."

Judge Crabb does go on to discuss the potential influence of campaign money on judges' decision making by chastising the defenders of the ethics rule's dependence on a statement made by former Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, but Judge Crabb takes pains to point out that Justice O'Connor wasn't addressing the sort of specific instance Koschnick raises either: "[O'Connor's] criticism was not of personal solicitations in particular but judicial fund raising generally."

In conclusion, Judge Crabb writes:
If defendants believe that some potential donors will feel coerced because they are likely to appear before that judge, less restrictive (and more effective) responses would include limiting solicitations of those who are frequent litigants or requiring recusal when anyone who was solicited appears in that judge’s court.
That is, according to Siefert, it's the lawyers in Judge Koschnick's scenario who donated to Chief Justice Abrahamson's campaign who are the ones that may be feeling coerced, not the Chief.

Except Koschnick doesn't tell us whether the lawyers he has in mind are "frequent litigants" — however "frequency" might be adduced — or whether they were "solicited" by the Chief (they weren't; they donated because they wanted to, and because they can).

Furthermore, Judge Crabb noted the results of a study published in a law review article that found that "75% of all cases coming before [the] Wisconsin Supreme Court in [the] 1990s involved [a] lawyer, firm or company that had contributed to one or more of its justices."

So once again we're presented with an example of Koschnick cherry picking through the data and finding a singular instance to suit his purposes. Later on he was at it again, mining not just individual decisions from a collection of more than 3,500, but even individual sentences, completely out of context, from individual opinions.*

And, of course, Koschnick never mentions that lawyers employed by the firm representing the adverse party in his carefully selected example have made contributions to every justice on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, not just the Chief.

Ultimately, if Judge Crabb was advocating any extrajudicial recommendations at all beyond the narrow holding in the case — that of invalidating the three ethics provisions — they were in favor of public financing of judicial election campaigns, which also happens to have been Chief Justice Abrahamson's stated position for years. And she expressly maintained that position again yesterday.

Finally, it's remarkably ironic for the strict constructionist Judge Koschnick to be making positive appeals to dicta beyond the central holding in Siefert, as he has elsewhere criticized the Chief Justice for fashioning exactly those.

Which is to say, were Judge Crabb of the "judicial conservative" sort that Koschnick claims to admire and presents himself to be, those dicta wouldn't even exist to use, abuse, or otherwise appeal to.

According to Judge Koschnick's "judicial philosophy," judges should confine themselves to the specific questions presented by the case before them and not attempt to establish broader legal rules, which he disapprovingly refers to as "legislating from the bench."

But for some reason Koschnick doesn't criticize Judge Crabb for venturing beyond the specific questions presented in Siefert. He instead purports to conveniently locate within that extraneous verbiage some validation for his ill-concealed political axe grinding.

This "judicial philosophy" is apparently adjustable to whatever Judge Koschnick finds accommodating, wherever he can find it, and, in this latest instance, whether it says so or not. In that respect, he's far more of a "judicial activist" than his political opponent ever was.

* Dutifully trumpeted by the Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel along with other various organs of the Wisconsin press, which are telling us this morning how Chief Justice Abrahamson must defend herself against Judge Koschnick's spurious accusations of "judicial activism."

Journal-Sentinel reporter and forum panelist Steven Walters even went so far as to demand from the Chief Justice a response to Judge Koschnick's charges of being "60% pro-criminal," to which a perfectly appropriate rejoinder would have been: 'Because they are idiotic, fallacious, pandering, methodologically flawed, and, most importantly, deliberately misrepresentative of the role of the court.'

But fortunately Chief Justice Abrahamson is by an astronomically ginormous measure more diplomatic than I.